Before The Chosen, Dallas Jenkins' What If… hit theaters in 2010.

It's a Wonderful Life—–modern day. What If...follows Ben Walker (Kevin Sorbo), a businessman who abandoned his faith. One day, Ben wakes up living the life he was destined for—married to his college sweetheart (Kristy Swanson) and serving as a small-town pastor. The film also features memorable performances by John Ratzenberger and Debby Ryan, packed with human, faith, and family.