Too Big- How To Tell and How To Get More Accountability
Bruce Thatcher, the founder of History Speaks Today, is talking about his latest book, Too Big? Leaders of big organizations are generally shielded from effective accountability for their actions or for the actions of employees and agents. In Too Big,...
The Bill Martinez Show is broadcast live Monday - Friday at 1PM ET.
The Bill Martinez TV Show is viewed on Talk 4 TV (www.talk4tv.com).
The Bill Martinez Radio Show is broadcast on W4CY Radio (www.w4cy.com) part of Talk 4 Radio (www.talk4radio.com) on the Talk 4 Media Network (www.talk4media.com).
The Bill Martinez Podcast is also available on Talk 4 Podcasting (www.talk4podcasting.com), iHeartRadio, Amazon Music, Pandora, Spotify, Audible, and over 100 other podcast outlets.
0:00 The topics and opinions expressed in the following show are solely those of the hosts and their guests and not those of W FORCY Radio. It's employees are affiliates. We make no recommendations or endorsements for radio show, program, services, or products mentioned on air or on our web. No liability, explicit or implied shall be extended to W FORCY Radio. It's employees are affiliates. Any questions or comments should be directed to those show hosts. Thank you for choosing W FORCY Radio. Well, good afternoon. Great to have you with us.
0:40 I'm Bill Martinez. Welcome to the show. We're going to have Bruce Thatcher joining us in just a moment. He is the founder of History Speaks Today, and we're talking about his latest book, Too Big. Leaders of big organizations are generally shielded from effective accountability for their actions and for the actions of employees an agents. In his new book, Too Big, the thirty year veteran and marketing and management examines five high profile, historical and current examples of where accountability was and is flawed or missing. It shows how such people are often up subject to effective accountability by the organizations they lead. It also shows many of the ploys that were and are used to evade accountability. Bruce Stature joins us, Now, hey, Bruce, how are you, buddy?
1:30 I'm fine. It good to be with the Bill Well, always good. I always enjoy our time together. It's so thought provoking, and especially this new book, Too Big. Tell us what prompted this this book? Well, you know, I need to give a little background first that will maybe put it in perspective. Okay, when I first started, before I first started writing, and I was in the Kansas City area, I often got concerned about why don't we learn from history's lessons? Because we never seemed to do that exactly. And I thought about that a bit. I kept thinking about it after I moved down here to Texas to retire, and I came to the conclusion that the reason we don't learn history's lessons is because generally we're not taught history's lessons. We're taught to who, when, where?
2:23 Why? Of history? We marched through time sequences and people and places, But nowhere in my experience in history, with one exception, was the question of so what ever addressed exactly? So what does it mean for us today? So I decided to deal with the deal with the so what, and I established history speaks today, and the whole intention of all the books is the so what on some particular lesson of history. This is a fifth book, and it like all the others, the lesson is in the subtitle it's too big as a title on the subtitle is how to tell and how we can get build more accountability. And that tells you what the lesson is and what the book's all about. You know, Bruce, you're so spot on.
3:14 I've never heard anybody put it in those terms, in terms of, you know, we go, we take a class, we get a task, we get a grade, and we move on to the next uh, you know, the next objective of what the classroom syllabus says that we should do. And that's unfortunate. And I think that's a perfect reason why we don't learn, because we really don't. We really don't study. We we just we just do it just to get a grade and and and cover a class objective, as opposed to really drilling down and coming away with some sort of knowledge. It's almost like, uh, you know, in a general education class, that's what it is. It just covers it and gives you a broad brush approach. Unless you you happen to decide to you're going to major in history, then maybe you might have a little bit more opportunity to do a deeper dive. Right, Yeah, And what I learned, I think what I practice practically all the way through school was what are the techniques to pass the tests and get a good grade? Exactly? And I suspect that that's what most people experiences in approaching school. We talk about education in terms of teaching students how to think critically, right, and that happens sometimes, but I think too far too infrequently. Well, and the unfortunate thing, Bruce, is there you are. You're in a classroom, I mean depending, I mean it could be twenty, it could be fifty or so
4:45 people there. And can you imagine if you exercise the cumulative brain trust of everybody in that classroom, including the professor, to address these issues? Boy man, I'll tell you, people would get more out of history than they've ever realized before. Unquestionably but unfortunately, at least in my experience and teaching of history, history was you learn these facts and you spin them back, right. I don't remember only one exception I mentioned earlier, I don't remember ever having a discussion about, well, what does it mean for us? What is it all about? That exception was a class in naval science.
5:28 Thet the history of the United States and World Sea power was it was the subject that we studied battles, and we studied the details, and there was always as so what, because it was leading to presumably a life potential, life situations, and saying, if you're in these situations, do this, don't do this? Exactly? Well, in your in your book Too Big, you address some key individuals and you you take them by case case one, we break down speaking of so what Robert Clive and the East India Company break that down for us. The East India Company, I think it still exists in some minuscule way to day, But in the sixteen, seventeen and eighteen hundreds it was the literally the biggest company on earth. It was huge.
6:25 The only thing I remember studying in history about the East India Company was the Boston Tea Party, and they threw tea overboard from their ships. But the East India Company literally had its own army. It was authorized to have its own army. It was authorized to conquer lands and do whatever wanted to and the subject of Robert Clive joined the East India Company as a very young man, not particularly notable in any particular area, but he went to joined the Eastern India Company and he went to India. India had just East India Company had a trading relationship with some of the some of the princes of India, and he went to India as East India Companies first as just just an employee, and he quickly worked up to a position of some responsibility where he was commanding armies, fighting battles against the French and the competitors, but also against some of the Indian representatives. And he made a lot of money.
7:32 He made a lot of money, and he went back, he sort of retired, He got married, he went back and he went to back to back to London, and he blew all the money in various fashions. And then the East India Company said, come back to us, and they sent him back to to to India again, and he literally went through the process without going in the details. The East India Company in India under his leadership, literally conquered the company country. Wow, their army was bigger than the Army of Great Britain. Well, what happened was, of course he got very corrupted. He some of the relationships are very corrupted. He went back to London, he was criticized, He tried to get in Parliament, he didn't make it, and ultimately he literally probably committed suicide. He died at a young age. But what it illustrated was one of the principles of accountability is time dynamics. Accountability relates to timely communications. In those days, communications was a one year cycle from London to India and back and allowed him to just do whatever he wanted to exactly. Yeah, it's amazing. Uh you know when you when you consider that dynamic and how it played in, uh
9:07 played into the role. So here here he is Robert Clive, very successful, pretty much bankrupts himself, goes back to East India company, reinvents himself and reinvents himself with even much more power, right, much more power, and and he is he if you bought a point at any one person, he's probably the person that made India a colony of the United Kingdom. The United Kingdom, Great Britain got ultimately after his death some years Great Britain took over the UK, took away from East India, Company took possession of India, and and of course the history of India we know. Well, maybe if Clive hadn't been so arrogant and leveraged his control of India and turned it over to the crown sooner he may have entered into Parliament. Might add a different story, just you. Probably might. He might have kept his millions, yea, and might have lived longer, long enough to enjoy it.
10:16 Well, Bruce Thatcher is our guest. He's the founder of History Speaks today, and we're taking a look at his brand new book Too Big Leaders of big organizations that are generally shielded from effective accountability. The subtitle of the book how to tell and how to get more accountability. The next story that you break down in case two has always been one that I've been very fascinated with, Bruce, and that's John D. Rockefeller with a standard oil company. John D. Rockefeller was a self made man. I mean, he came from small beginnings and he went ultimately he went to the to the oil patch, which in those days was in northwest Pennsylvania, and he worked there just a little bit, not He never owned a oil well, never owned an oil well or an oil well least. But what he did in those days is that there were a lot of little companies that were refining oil. The value of petroleum oil was as a competitor to whale oil for lighting. There was no other envisioned use for it at the time, but that was a huge, huge market. So John D. Rockefeller decided that the way to keep them, and there were all kinds of price pressures, the way to keep the prices up was to control the refining of oil. So he opened
11:52 his refinery in Cleveland, and he and he bought other refiners, and he coerced, and that was his pattern all the way through his career, was to pressure and coerce competitors to join him if they didn't. If they did join him, they became very, very wealthy people. If they didn't join him, they typically were ruined. Because he controlled the railroads in so far as their relationships were with the oil business. When pipelines came along, he quickly controlled the pipelines. He had tankers, the worldwide fleets of ships, and and he was very little some but very little of what he did was actually against the law and under the laws at the time. And he was a brilliant man, did a lot of How was he able to get away with that bruce? Well, because he got away with it, because he managed to have more probably i'd say more audacity than anything else. He ultimately bribed congressman. For a long time, he held off the anti trust legions in both in the states and of Pennsylvania and in the and in the Congress.
13:15 And when it got to getting people out of out of his way, he did or his agents did, is the more accurate thing. He did hire people, i mean thugs to to work violence some people who were competing with him. Wow, he has his ways, huh, he had his ways. And and and after the Sermon Trust Act was finally enacted and they brought the case against the Standard Oil Trust, it wasn't the Standard Oil Company at the time. It was a very interesting thing that he did and it was copied later in one of the other cases. He set up an organization to defeat the anti trust laws and business laws of the various states they operated in, and it was called a trust. It was the first time that had been done. And he owned shares of the trust and he was he was just had an equal share with everybody else, but some people were more equal than others of the case, and he absolutely nothing happened in the Standard Oil Trust that he didn't approve on. He knew, well, I argue, he knew everything that went on. He was he destroyed paper trails, if you will, and had some deniability because you know, I just own
14:46 a few shares of the trust. That's right after after the Justice Department broke up the Standard Oil Company into a whole bunch of other companies, he ended up being them for a while, majority owner of every single one of those companies, and he became the richest man in the world after Standard All Company was broken up. Well, that's that's amazing. Maybe he was the one that originated the idea of plausible deniability, Bruce, what do you think? Well, I don't know if he originated it, but he sure did it. He had a I mean, he went absolutely out of his way to not be have a paper trail and not be associated with some of the decisions that the trust entered into, and plausible deniability was a big part of his way to avoid accountability. What can I do, I'm just one, you know, I'm just one voice and all this thing. I didn't know that these people were beating up the guys trying to build a competitive pipeline. He it's it's it's a part of Rockefeller that doesn't show up in the usual history books. Ida Tarboo in her book Muckraking book really went into that sort of thing. But it's a I think it's a good case of the plausibility right,
16:18 of the plausible deniability approach to avoiding accountability. Well, he had to be a smart guy, Bruce, I mean, because he was like a step or two ahead of the government. Uh, you know, the government's still you know, trying to get his legs underneath itself. Uh you know, we're in this industrial revolution. It's happening at mock five speeds, and Rockefeller is ahead of it and probably realizing that he had a certain amount of time that he could get away with it until until he couldn't get away with it anymore. I think there's a little question that cocker Feller was a brilliant man, a genius. He recognized, he recognized where the opportunities were, and he had absolutely no compunction about doing whatever it was necessary to get them.
17:12 But I think that actually that's a a description of almost anybody who enters into it, goes into an enterprise and develops it, either from sprats or going into it, works their way to the top. They all tend to be very very smart people. They're not They're not idiots at all, exactly. Well, Bridge, don't you think a little bit that they maybe understand that there's a beginning and end with all this stuff, that it will just never, you know, keep on going. Is that you just make you know, make hay while the sun shines, and knowing that their competition could be outside circumstances. I mean, you know, I guess in studying some of these geniuses and uh, you know, emperors of industry so to speak, is that you know very few of them really. I mean, no, no question. They were audacious, and they were arrogant, and there is hubrists and all that that went in it. But I think there was also an element of reality that drove them as well. I don't know, maybe I'm i'm i'm I'm seeing too much, but I just think that maybe these guys are just so much smarter than we realize. I think that again, there surely are exceptions but I think that it is characteristic of all the
18:42 people who rise to the top that they have a wide vision, a wide range of vision. They know what's going on. Usually they know what they want to do and where they're going to go, and usually they want to absolutely maintain control of all the circumstances that they can. Question. The question that comes that, surely the many of them come up against, is how far do I go in order to get done what I want to get want to get done? Exact. Rockefeller had the advantage that there were very few laws against any of the things he wanted to do until late in the late in the game, as it were, exactly, And that's not the case with some of the people who come later on exactly. But he knew then as we do now, is that it doesn't hurt to know which politicians to Greece, right, oh yeah, oh yeah. Rockefeller. Rockefeller always had we'd call it today, We would say, well, he had these these senators in his pocket or whatever. He always in the Pennsylvania legislature and then in the in the US Congress. He always has had people who are what we would say, is I said, in our pocket, in his pocket, right, you know Brissett, it almost is a little bit frustrating because you think, uh, okay, if you work hard and you demonstrate merit,
20:15 that you can be successful. But in order to play at the levels that Rockefeller and these other leaders do, you got to understand the totality of the game that you're entering into is that it is. It can be dirty, can it. You have to understand the game. And it's even we like to compare things to sports, and we say, well, it's a game. It's more life encompassing than just a game. You have to put your you have to commit yourself to the whole thing. You have to commit when in starting a business and working a business. I have some experience of that. You do surely you have to commit yourself to twelve hours a day and more than that seven to six, seven days a week exactly be willing to do everything. And they were, they would do it, they would they would get it done. And I think that that was a characteristic of almost anybody who works to the top. And we always we keep talking about and most of my examples are corporations, but it applies to government and non government entities just as well as it does corporations exactly. Well, you know these, as you say, these these industry titans, they understood the power of government and by getting close to it. So in some ways the traditions
21:47 of previous empires continue. And that is that, you know, if you couldn't be king, at least get as close to the king as possible in order to garner favor and advantage. Right, absolutely, league, I have I moving along just a little bit. I One of the interesting cases I liked best was the one on General Electric and Ralph Cordner. Yes, okay, I was working for General Electric during those years, oh did okay? Uh? And it was a It was fascinating for me to do the research on it because while I knew the price fixing trials were going on, it was sort of vaguely. I didn't work in those particular departments. It was incredible for me to think back about how absolutely unaware I was. I mean I was, I was a big I didn't you know this. These things didn't mean anything to me at the time I was there. I did refer to and one of Ralph Cordner was I think it was an expert at creating plausible deniability. He created or reinvented and and strengthened policy called twenty point five that says it is it is against the General Electric policy to engage in any collusion or price fixing with competitors. Further than that, I, as a very young damp behind the years my college person, I was called into a meeting in a country club the Chicago area and all of our employee not all
23:19 of our employees, but all of our marketing employees were there and we had a presentation of the Sherman Anna Trust Actor Clayton Act, a couple more, and then a presentation from the company that says, here is our policy twenty point five, and now you sign it. And I had signed all of a sudden signed it, and then it was mailed into New York, and you know, I was, okay, we'll do that into New York and into the file and forget all about it. But Ralph Corner didn't forget all about it, because that was a huge defense at his trial and the trial of the General Electric people, was that I couldn't know. I had no reason to suppose that anybody would do these things because we have a policy against it. Yeah, here it is, it's documented and like they say in a court of law, there's nothing like a document to defend your case.
24:12 Right, that's right, that's right. And so that was that was an interesting personal experience on him. One of the cases, of course is j Edgar Hoover. That's not a corporation, right, And and j Edgar Hoover, I think never had his eye on an endgame. J Edgar Hoover was never going to leave his job. He was a king. This was his creation, the FBI, and he was on top of it. And everybody better understand it, because he was absolutely never going to leave. Yes, yeah, exactly and uh. And he had quite the you know, quite the information that he had on everybody, whether there were an enemy or not.
25:02 Right. He started collecting personal information, using agents to do this, and making files on anybody he thought might ever be of any use to him or any influence on him. And he started this fairly early in his career. And he just kept doing it, kept doing it, kept doing it. And after a while there was the you know, the well Jediker Hoover's files, you really had him, he didn't really have him. He would and he would use the information ruthlessly to get what he wanted, and presidents were not willing to cross him nobody because it was he probably had incriminating information on everybody who could affect him. And there's some cases instances in the book where he used that information to absolutely score senators who were opposing his budgets or anything like that, right exactly. Well, you know the thing is, let's face it, there's just something about power and the bureaucracy and government.
26:11 You know, they're not a bunch of altar boys, not a bunch of saints, right. I mean, there's certain attributes about people who are in you know, that line of business we have. When I was in a in a scruggel area, I got involved in politics and one of the things that happened is I got elected to the school board on very idealistic kinds of things because some people, uh came to me and said, you know, here are things that going on with schools and that's it's awful. We need to fix them. And this is before all those bad books that they put out these days, right yeah, oh yeah, this was a long time ago. So I listened to all this and I said, well, yeah, that sounds to be like it needs fixing. I'll run. And there was a campaign and I and another guy won against two people who had been on the school board from the time it was formed. And and in that experience I learned a lot of my politics. I learned to follow the money.
27:21 I learned that the politics is local. The biggest interest is wherever the money is, and the school board, the school district budgets are the biggest part of all local politics expenditures exactly. And what I learned, and it was it was told to me and I didn't quite appreciate at the time. It was that when people get elected to office, they often maybe even usually are elected for very a realistic, idealistic reasons. They really want to go and do a good job. Then they go off to Washington and man, that establishment sucks them in as fast as can be. And all of their obviously their exceptions, but all of their ideals get rationalized the way because here's this, here's this wonderful stuff that they get into. Exactly. And the same person who was telling me that said, now you're gonna you're gonna face, You're gonna it's gonna happen to you on a school board. You're gonna find that that the company that's paving the parking lot at the school. They'll do things like they'll say to you, the school board member or president.
28:40 As I became, they'll say, hey, you know what, we got this job done, and we have this asphalt left over, and why don't we just you know, I know you don't have your driveway page. Why don't we just otherwise they're gonna throw it away. Why don't we just come out over there and put on your driveway? And and you say, I mean the normal thing that you said, Well, that's fine. It doesn't cost the school anything. They're paying them. They're not paying any more because of it said okay, or the same thing with grass seat or anything. But then you're you're you're a bit sucked in because the next contracts come along, right and you remember, yeah, and uh, it could just get deeper and deeper and deeper. You know, they got a hook in you.
29:27 Yeah, yeah, it doesn't it doesn't take much. It's also subtle. And the thing is, like you say, especially for these politicians that are elected and if they if it's on a federal level, you know, they go they go to the belt Way and then their initial freshman orientation and they go in with all their ideology and ideas and agenda that they want to you know, pass, and they're all excited about it. And then the first orientation meaning tells them what the most important thing about about their being them being members of Congress, and the number one job is to get reelected. And they say, and that starts today. So suddenly that's the most important thing. And as you say, it's quid pro quo, because then you find, you know, there's a lot of backs to be scratched, because you'll you'll get involved in a network where you know, one hand is helping another, and it's it's quite the web, isn't it. It is?
30:29 And I'm sure I haven't been an official capacity in Washington, but I'm sure that many and many have elected politicians in Washington who fall into this trap are able to rationalize every single one of their decisions and say, well, this is really this is for the good of fills that lie, and this isn't against the law, and well, of course I have to do these kinds of things, or I wouldn't be able to do those kinds of things. But as soon as I get into that, in my opinion, they're sucked in without they're part of the establishment. Well, and the thing is, Bruce, everybody's doing it, right, I mean insider trading. You know, you'd say, well, you know that's it's not exactly illegal, it you know, it's kind of great hurt, right, Yeah, Yeah, there's always there's always rationalization that will that will allow them to feel good about what they're doing right exactly, And that breaks down the tenants of accountability right there, because you know, they don't have to answer the tough questions because they're part of the crowd, right, they're part of the and the crowd, they're part of the elected officials, particularly in Washington. Is accountability depends as kind of an hierarchical concept. That is to say, there are people
32:00 who rise up through the organization, and you're always to be accountable. You always have a boss, you always have a supervisor, You always have somebody that you are accountable too. And if it's effective accountability, that person has the ability to effect your well being. They can decide whether you get a raise or not. They can decide whether you get fired or not. So when when there is that relationship, you have a chance at effective accountability. But elected officials, it's kind of a different sort of thing. They don't report to a person. We're like to say, well, they report to the people, but that isn't a person exactly, And they have to then they have to not justify what they're doing, they have to persuade a majority to reelect them. Happens on boards of direct too. And if you're if you are responsible to more than one person, then you don't have accountability.
33:08 You don't serve two masters. This is a problem that we can't fix in a democracy because we believe very strongly that the people should decide who who represent them. And and so you have this question of what do you do about elected leaders in terms of accountability? What do you do about about corporate presidents in terms of accountability? Who will report to a board of directors? That's a number of people. Well, there are some things I think you can do. We wait, I think we could suggest in terms of elected officials, but why don't we have term limits? Right? But that's not going to happen. That's not going to happen. We're going to have to do our best with with our elected officials to impose or demand an accountability and to do that. We're going to have to keep their feet to the fire.
34:07 We're gonna have to ask them questions. We're gonna have to force them to face up as much as we can decisions they've made. Yeah, well, Bruce, I think I think also what we realized here recently, and that is preserving the integrity of the vote, to make sure that every vote counts. I mean, you talk about non accountability, and you talk about everybody doing it, so it shouldn't be a problem. And that is where there's ballot stuffing. There's manipulation of the ballot that's going on from state to state. We suspect it, do we know, do we have hardcore evidence?
34:50 We have some indications. There's lots of smoke out there, but you know, there's not enough interest to really look into this. But if this is truly going to be a government for by we the people, if you and I have discussed many times, well, then the power needs to be back in the hands of we the people. And if the vote is the most important thing that we have in which to maintain said power, then we need to honor that vote to make sure that there is integrity, that there's free and fair elections that votes aren't getting canceled because illegal immigrants are allowed to cast a vote, or you know, you've got ballot harvesters who are going into nursing homes where people can you know, barely speak a sentence, and they're you know, getting a ballot from them, or you know, putting their name on the ballot. And that's not even to mention, you know, people who have died, like in California. I mean, they got people on the voting roles that have died, and it's pretty amazing in California.
35:45 I think that I find it quite interesting that people can die in California as Republicans and the Democrats are able to raise them from the dead and get them to vote Democrat. I don't know that California innovation. When I was living in Chicago, you were very much aware that the Democratic machine voted a lot of people from from a graveyard. Yeah, yeah, that was the same. That was the saying. My good friend down in South Florida, who worked in the machinery of the Chicago politics, he always said, when they thought that the vote was over, they'd say, wait, we have to get the cemetery vote. Ye, that's right. Election Shenneigans are not new to our current times. You know, they went on way back in history, well, seventeen hundred, Bruce, I was looking back. I said, how long has voter fraud been going on? And what spurred it on?
36:43 Of course, was you know the former Attorney General, Eric Holder, who swore he looked in the camera, said there's no such thing as voter fraud. And I and even then, I'm going, how could there be no such thing as voter fraud? When people are getting arrested, they're spending time in jail for voter fraud. How in an attorney general makes such an ignorant statement. I think I think too many politicians, Well, first, they're experts at what they do. They're experts at what they do. And I think too many politicians understand very clearly that Hitler was perfect at it. The great lie tell it often enough and people begin to believe it. And the bigger the better, the bigger the better. And a thing that I think is very a very strong factor is our increasingly diminished attention span. Oh yeah, I mean we don't a lot of I argue, a lot of people can't think past next week. But we don't we don't tend to think about the future and what that happens. That works well for incumbent politicians because they can practically rely that the electorate will not remember things they've said and things they've done when it comes time to the next election. So I don't know what to do about those things. As I said before, how about terminal us. That's right exactly. We can talk things like that, but of
38:19 course they're not going to happen. They're not going to happen. Well, we're told in the Bible and Daniel twelve four, And I've always appreciated this, Bruce, because I think this is where we are right now. It says that even in the time of the end, many shall run to and fro, and knowledge will be increased. Well, you know, here we are in the information age. We've got incredible power in the palm of our hands and our cell phones, and that information is there. But as you said, I think we're so overwhelmed by the information that we have failed to become discerners of the right knowledge that are going to presume they're going to, you know, render the right results. Does that make sense? Every bit of it? Absolutely? I think that back in the days when when our information came to us, not quite as fast, not quite as as on the scene kind of thing, but it came to us in print form usually, and we learned to read, and we learned to read it, and we didn't have one hundred or a thousand different impressions to deal with in the same frame sphere of time. Right. I think that we were that we did a lot better at figuring out what was what was actually going on.
39:46 We didn't know as many things, but the things we knew about we tended to know about in more depth. Right. And I think that tremendous volume of information, the smartphone mentality and all of this kind of thing. Oh, I gotta see it, I gotta sit it is not it is not true that you can multitask on several things at the same time. You can switch back and forth. But if but if you've got all that stuff going on, it's really tough. It's really tough to get into it. Well. And on top of that roost the knowledge or at least the information, let's say, information that's being born out there, how much of it is the misinformation? I mean, we've got the government claiming, you know, other people are purveyors of misinformation when they themselves continue to lie at every turn, and they want to establish, you know, a department of misinformation and going, I mean, you guys are propagandists yourself, so I mean this whole idea, But this is why we the people must step up. And you've heard me say this before. I always urge our audience. You must own your own knowledge. Don't just take our word from it. You know.
41:04 Fortunately, you know we have people were so blessed to have people with the experience like Bruce Thatcher, historian who brings weight to the topic. And it's up for you. Hopefully you're motivated enough say, you know what, I'm going to check this out myself and know for myself so that when I address this issue, I'm not speaking with the depth of a bumper sticker or an eight seconds SoundBite. Right right. Look at one of the things that reporters do. Good reporters do as they as they look for corroborataortive information. They want more than just this one statement of effect. They want other statements that tend to corroborate that thing, and then they can begin to build what they What I was taught in journalisms, they begin to build what is a credible story exactly. I think that happen as much as I'd like it to happen today. But we can do that as individuals. My sister's a doctor and she years ago she said to me, you're responsible for your own health, nobody else, and that applies to your own well being and exidy to your own information. You're responsible to make sure that you're getting the whole story as best you can. Exactly when you concentrate and you take all of your news in terms of sound bites and headlines and don't read down to the third
42:34 paragraph and all this kind of thing, you're not living up to your responsibility, in my opinion, And we all do this in some areas, but today it just gets overwhelming. The vent of social media has made this just kind of the standard way we go about our daily lives, and social media is social media is of course. The fifth case in the book has to do with Mark Zuckerberg, and Mark Zuckerberg again was brilliant. He's a brilliant person, absolutely no doubt about that. He is arguably also well intentioned.
43:22 I mean, you get into now, you get into invade about things. But he's not a bad person, but he's like Rockefeller. He controls absolutely nothing happens with Facebook Meta and there are other platforms that he does not approve of. And you can read in this case how various things that were happening caused him real anguish. But he always responded in terms of, well, I will it work out for me, and we'll set up we'll set up an algorithm to do this or whatever it is. And and he never he never claimed to be associated with one ideology or another. But things tend to come through, right, and it's social media is one of the greatest blessings of our of our age and one of the greatest ills of our age because of the way we as people allow it to take care of us. Well we also British. We end up we only get about five minutes left here.
44:36 But you know, we also end up identifying with people that we really don't know. It's almost like we we imagine something about them and we're really not dealing with reality in some of these cases. And uh, and we find ourselves taking other people's words for you a word for it, when they themselves haven't you know, either, they haven't been forthright about their intention. I think I think Mark Zuckerberg made it real clear in the last election what his intention was. I think I'd be curious to find out that if if the winds, you know, came from a different direction for him, that would serve him more directly. I'd be curious to see if he would suddenly become conservative. Well, as it gets older, maybe maybe I think that I think that some of the some of the things that I think you need to do, particularly to improve the accountability question is is update a little bit of the wording in the sermon and various other anti trust acts so that they're brought in, remove that shielding they have that allows them to say, well, we're just a media, we don't have any control over what's there.
45:54 And I see that article two thirty. I agree with percent yes, but again that's that's a that's a plausible that deniability instrument institutionalized exactly, Yeah, and we need to change it. Well, and of course you know it cost him some money and and uh and here it is and of course it served him well, especially now when they've aligned themselves with one party the power, the party that happens to be in power. So it works very effectively, Bruce Thatcher is with us and we're talking about his new book Too Big, How to Tell and how to get more accountability. Bruce, in these last three and a half minutes that we have together, I'm going to let you summarize and help us understand what the takeaway should be and what we should draw from this. Because accountability starts with me and you, doesn't it, it does we. We each of us have our own chaine of accountability.
46:57 Were accountability somebody or something at Those who have deep religious beliefs feel an accountability to the god. But Rockefeller was one of those, and that's easy to rationalize a way, and I think there's always the temptation to do that. I think what we have to do is realize that we want accountability even from powerful people. Realize it's a very natural thing for them to be in a position of power so that they can avoid most accountability. It's natural, it's not evil people behave that way, and then, understanding that, say well, what can we do to improve the accountability of those situations. What can we do about the relationships between boards of directors and chief executive officers, What can we do between the relationships independent agencies in the government and the entities to which they presumably report, but they never do exactly and think about those things, and there are some things we can do. We cannot make everybody accountable.
48:21 Individuals will be accountable as much as they want to be, or feel that it's in their nature to be, or as much as they feel it's the right thing to do. But there's always always going to be powerful people who rationalize around those things or deliberately go around those things exactly. So let's do the things we can. And there there are some well, Bruce, I believe that there needs to be a clear infrastructure. I believe we have some of those, you know, when they call them laws and other boundaries that need to be adhered to, and when said laws are violated, then there needs to be immediate punishment. You know. It's it's like the Book of ecclesiastic says that because you know punishment, you know, or sin is not punished immediately, it gets complicated, it's snowballs. And this is where we are right now, is that accountability is something that must be exercised with more of a sense of urgency, is the way I read it, Bruce.
49:22 I'm gonna let you summarize and take us out right now to wrap everything's up in terms of a final conclusion. Go ahead. I think I think that we ought to understand the nature of accountability at high levels, and we ought to understand that we need to change laws in particular to improve that accountability. And the changes are not very great, although they would be very significant. I think we need to do those things. One of the things I think we understand need to understand is, oh, well we have a law against that. You know what we so it's so got so and so company got fined a billion dollars for us and such. That's pocket change. Exactly, it's pocket change. It doesn't mean anything. And we need to make the I don't like to call it the punishment. We may need to make the results fit the situation so that they so that they cause or so that people will be aware of them and behave in a more accountable fashion. Exactly.
50:35 Well. Bruce Thatcher, author of the book Too Big, How to Tell and How to Get More Accountability of the book is available at all the usual places, and you can go to Bruce's website Bruce the Website for our audience, The website is History Speaks Today dot com and you can find all the books there. You can find all the links to where you can get them, and we're happy to see you join it. Well. Bruce Thatcher, I cannot thank you enough. Appreciate the time, my friend, you take care. You're two Our thanks to Bruce Thatcher for being with us today. For more information and to be a part of this mighty Martinez movement to return to God and to save our country, go to Bill Martine's show dot com. May God bless you and keep you, make his face shine upon you, and may He be gracious unto you and give you peace. Thank you so much for being with us. Have a great day.
iHeartRadio
Spotify
Amazon Music
Pandora
Audible
Apple Podcasts
Spreaker
Podchaser
Podcast Addict
Castbox
Goodpods
PlayerFM
Podverse
Podyssey
Castro
RadioPublic
Overcast
RSS Feed
YouTube