The Year That Broke Politics That Still Resonates Today
In The Year That Broke Politics: Collusion and Chaos in the Presidential Election of 1968, Luke Nichter, historian and author draws on previously unexamined archives and numerous interviews and upends conventional understanding of the crucial...
The Bill Martinez Show is broadcast live Monday - Friday at 1PM ET.
The Bill Martinez TV Show is viewed on Talk 4 TV (www.talk4tv.com).
The Bill Martinez Radio Show is broadcast on W4CY Radio (www.w4cy.com) part of Talk 4 Radio (www.talk4radio.com) on the Talk 4 Media Network (www.talk4media.com).
The Bill Martinez Podcast is also available on Talk 4 Podcasting (www.talk4podcasting.com), iHeartRadio, Amazon Music, Pandora, Spotify, Audible, and over 100 other podcast outlets.
0:00 The topics and opinions expressed in the following show are solely those of the hosts and their guests and not those of W FORCY Radio. It's employees are affiliates. We make no recommendations or endorsements for radio show, program services, or products mentioned on air or on our web. No liability, explicit or implied shall be extended to W FORCY Radio. It's employees are affiliates. Any questions or comments should be directed to those show hosts. Thank you for choosing W FORCY Radio. Well, welcome to the Bill Martinez Show. Great to have you with us, sharing a part of your day. For more info on the show, you can check it out Bill Martinez Show dot com. We're gonna rewind a bit go back to nineteen sixty eight, the year that broke politics and that still resonates today. In the year that broke politics, collusion and chaos in the presidential election of nineteen sixty eight, our next guest, the historian Luke Nicker and author, draws on previously unexamined archives and numerous interviews and up ends conventional understanding of the crucial presidential campaign between Nixon, Vice President Humphrey, and former Alabama Governor George Wallace. It shows how it created a new template and toned for election battles, which still resonates, believe it or
1:30 not, in today's fractured political climate. Look, Nictar, welcome to the show. Good to have you with a sir, oh, thanks for having me on well as a historian and also as a professor of history, an opportunity to go back and take a look at nineteen sixty eight. Why did this stick out in your mind that in such a way that you said, Okay, this is a story that must be told. Well, I think often in history, you know, while there's many many books already written on the nineteen sixties, including the nineteen sixty eight election, I think oftentimes fifty years is about enough time for records to finally be declassified, for personal papers to be opened, you know. And so while this seems like an old topic, perhaps to summon your audience, this is really brand new for history because this period of history is really being now being written the late sixties, the nineteen seventies, and as you see in the book, there's lots of new evidence that has just been opened recently exactly. And then when it aligns with the contemporary narrative of today. You go, WHOA, there's a lot of similarity of things that have happened in sixty eight and how they're being cast and being revealed and understood here in the modern era. Yeah, that's right.
2:45 I remember one of the people I interviewed, Nixon's longtime speechwriter, Ray Price. He always used to say to me, if the eighteen sixties wasn't actual was a civil war, then the nineteen sixties was a kind of proxy civil war when you look at how stirred up the nation was civil on rust, the draft, the war in Vietnam, the counterculture movement. And I think just as you said there, I think many people are drawing parallels to today's politics. Well, and you bring up a good point here. You would think that we should have learned from the eighteen sixties. Fast forward one hundred years, and here we are reproducing. So it leads us to believe that somehow, maybe we didn't know the whole truth and nothing but and because without knowing the whole truth, how can you learn enough so that you don't repeat the same mistakes? Luke Well, and I you know, of course, the national media is always reminding us that we're more divided than we ever have been before. But hold on a second. You know, people who know their history know that as a nation, we've been through lots of other challenges prior to this, right, And you know, I think also there's a reminder here of what history is or isn't. You know, people will sometimes say to me, you know, I wasn't very good at history because I couldn't memorize people or places or dates, when in fact, history is much more than that. It's really never over because what history is is as we constantly have new evidence that forces us to challenge what we thought we knew, forces us to challenge our preconceived ideas. It's really a debate about who we are as a people and how we got here and maybe even a glimpse
4:17 of where we're headed next. And so it's not just the static set of events that we all can learn through through books. It's really are The debate is over the meaning and the importance over the second events. And that's the part that never changed, that that never end is and how much more is revealed, Like you said, here, it is fifty years later people are talking where before they wouldn't. Archives are opened up information now available that wasn't then. So there's only so much we can know from present you know, from present day history, that will still be revealed to us down the road, you know, many decades forward. Because that seems to be the pattern, and Luke, isn't it it is? You know, And I'm surprised, obviously I've a twentieth century US political historian. But every once in a while you read about someone in an attic who has a trunk of records from the Civil War, and we made a new image of Abraham Lincoln that's never been seen, or a document from the Gettysburg address or something. And so I think, you know, even much further distant events in history, we can still discover important new things about. But I think in this book, I think the two things that are the most different of any other book that's been written on the nineteen sixties. First of all, this is the first book to have a cooperation from the four major sides. So I'm going President Lyndon Johnson, his vice president Hubert Humphrey, Richard Nixon, and a governor George Wallace. And I was able to talk to all of the families and about eighty five total staffers who are surprisingly are still around fifty years And I
5:50 make the controversial argument that outgoing President Lyndon Johnson actually preferred his longtime rival, Republican Richard Nixon as his successor in the White House because Johnson concluded that it was better for his own legacy. And so that's really quite a different take, you know, than any other book on the nineteen sixties, right, And that's the collusion that you're talking about in talking to these four different historical figures. Was there an agreement, was there a convergence in terms of narrative of you know, that era of nineteen sixty eight. Well, the difficult thing is, you know, some of them were closer to the boss, so to speak, than others. Some are more on in the periphery.
6:35 Most of the senior people are gone now. And one of the most difficult things as a writer, you know, as a historian, I spend almost every week in an archive. I was just up at the Reagan Library the Nixon Library are both closed here in southern California. And you know, assembling looking at records as a bit like assembling puzzle pieces, you know, of a jigsaw puzzle and you try to fit together the story at what's new, what was overlooked before it's newly released. But records memos don't say a lot about personalities and personal networks sometimes, and so talking to people really does help to confirm, well, I do remember something about that. I don't trust fifty year old memories. Myself. I can't remember what I had for breakfast most days. But people, people who are around who now with the passage of time, feel freer to talk things aren't politically sensitive. People still in politics, especially when their bosses are still in politics, a very unlikely to reveal anything that really changes your idea. So I think when you look at all the evidence, tapes and documents and talking to people and you triangulate between those, I think that's when it's possible to come up a new fresh take on a subject, even one that's been written about so many times. Well, Luke, help help our viewers understand. For you, as a researcher, when you go into a presidential library, you know, how do you approach this and you know what does it look like? Is it, you know, a typical library type setting, or you know, is there all
8:07 kinds of you know, special security. And then of course even when you actually start dealing with the actual historical documents, how accessibable are they? Well, that's a great question. I used to be a stafford at CSPAN and the best boss I ever had, Brian Lamb. He loved to ask writers that kind of process question, just like the kind that you're asking there. I would say, they're all a little different. And you look at all the archives that are in the back of the book. Some are federal government, some are state government, some are university campuses that personal papers. The most interesting one which has really featured a lot in the book is the Billy GRAHAMLA Library and Archive in Charlotte, and and some of these records are paper, some have been digitized, so you're looking on a computer screen. Some of the originals are very fragile, so they don't like to serve those to reachers researchers unless they really have to. But in case of the grand material, it was his records then were at Wheaton College, his alma mater, where he met his future wife, And there's a building on campus called the Billy Graham Center where they have they else have Chuck Colson's papers and other kind of relevant papers for his ministry in that time period, and the Billy Graham papers to see. In the midst of this research, Billy Graham died at age ninety nine in February of twenty eighteen, and this was totally unexpected to me, and the archivist a Wheaton College said, we had some things here that you might want to come look at, and one researchers looked at them for the British royal family, as it turned out, because he had extensive contacts with the royals, but no one's looked at the rest of him.
9:39 And so I went there and started going. I referred to a kind of in shorthand as the Graham Diaries. He called it his VIP notebooks. And these VIPs were presidents, and because he lived to be so long, it's over fifty volumes of contact with presidents, beginning in nineteen fifty with Harry Truman that go all the way to twenty fourteen with Barack Obama. And it can it's verbatim conversation, it's contents of their prayer life. At times it could be a part scrap book kind of when they're photographed together or a White House lunch menu with some notes he might have scratched on the back or maybe something the president leaned over and said to him. So it's really kind of part diary, part scrap book, and I was allowed to see just kind of the the I would call it the edge of the tip of the iceberg for the nineteen sixties, a very small part of the overall body of records, and it shows that he played an incredible role in the midst of this nineteen sixty at election. Incredible. We're talking with Luke Nicktir his book The Year That Broke Politics, Collusion and Chaos in the Presidential Election of nineteen sixty eight.
10:43 So you're going through the archives of Billy Graham. His notes probably that ran the full gamut of you know, specific quotes, maybe impressions, you know, for every president, what's stuck out, especially for you. Well, I guess may before we can get to that. How much time were you able to spend looking at these archives? Yes, so the grand materials are a little different. I mean, you go to a presidential library, the National Archives. Those are federal records, you know, written by people who are on the public payroll, who are accountable to you. Me and every other American and so those are generally open freely, freely, without restriction.
11:28 But you talk about private records. In the case of Gram's records, he was not a public official on the public payroll, so these records are still in private hands. And so I was allowed to see quite a bit of the diary. And then when it came to I then had to work with their General Council's office to get permission to use what you see in the book. And it's and it's, it's, it's and they were very cooperative and very easy to work with. I think my key takeaways are, you know, I think Graham always considered himself to be a lifelong Democrat, kind of a conservative, moderate Democrat, pro civil rights. Even in segregated facilities with his rallies, he never allowed that to happen. People freely mingled because you know, of course, he wanted to reach everyone, you know, across the political spectrum. And so the Gram material, some of them are I would call it a daily diary. Some of them are written, some of it's dictated and typed up after the fact. Some of it's, like I said, news articles and kind of part scrapbook, really kind of a hybrid diary, and in nineteen sixty eight, there's a whole chapter in the book that I call Messenger, because I think that accurately captures the role that he played. I think consistently Graham really wanted the best for the nation, for the country. He wasn't a partisan operative and any It's nothing that I see at all. He was really good friends with LBJ. But he also had this friendship with Nixon, and he passed messages between the two of them for a couple of year period at least. And the peak of this activity goes until about Labor Day in nineteen sixty eight, just a couple months before Americans voted that in November in nineteen sixty eight. And one of the messages he passes from Nick since Nixon to Johnson in the Oval Office is that as
13:03 president. Now, that's pretty speculative at that point for Nixon, because that a president Nixon would would not criticize Johnson by name, He would give him credit for the Vietnam War when it was all settled and over with, He would consult with him regularly in retirement given meaningful duties, and would give him as best a place in history as Nixon could possibly give him, and I thought that was just incredible to find a document like that Exactly at that point, Nixon, I think, has given Johnson all the ammunition he needs to blow up the Nixon campaign, of course, unless LBJ goes along with it and actually agrees with this, which is my argument in the book. And so Nixon was saying that to Johnson, I think it's exactly what he wanted to hear at a time that many in Johnson's own party were very critical of his presidency. And so it's it's it's what's fascinating about it really is even something bigger, a bigger idea that for all those of us who watch politics and who are interested, we're basically watching, say from the chief seats, kind of looking at actors on a stage. Right. So this book really raises a fascinating question that what if at key moments in US history of politics is not what we've been told it is. And I would argue that it was for sixty eight. Well, we've heard the terms kabuki theater often in the modern era, and I think you might be right, is that you know, there's so much happening, so much nuance I mean to the point.
14:26 Now, look, we find ourselves, you know, talking about the uniparty or the deep state, or some other force that's running the government other than elected officials. Well, that's exactly right, and I think, you know, deeply entrenched on both sides, you know, in the classroom, I kind of refer to it. So each party has kind of an activist wing. I refer to it as kind of the twenty percent. I don't know if that's the right number, but the idea is strange things happen in politics when when a small part of a party can kind of take over the party. And you see this occasionally, right, and this is this is a case. I think Lyndon Johnson perceived that those on his left the Democratic Party, we're moving the party in a direction that was away from call it, you know, the middle Middle America the pendulum of political public opinion in nineteen sixty eight, and this is the beginning of a time when millions of kind of moderate and southern Democrats were voting independently. We're across beginning to cross the aisle. So there's a very lot of seismic things going on here in US politics. Right in the background, of this book. Yeah, it's interesting because with Lyndon Baynes Johnson's support of Nixon. Uh, no doubt that lbj's presidency was very progressive. And I mean here he is, he, you know, elevates a war on poverty in which to this day we've spent twenty five thirty trillion dollars on the War on poverty. And after everything is said and done, you go, why, you know, what have we
15:56 done? I mean, the numbers have barely he moved after all that investment. But it's surprising to think that somebody that was of such progressive thought and really kind of opened the door, I think, for future progressivism of the Democratic Party. But yet he's willing to hit the pause button in order to ensure his own law legacy and to support Richard Nixon. Well, and it certainly would not make me popular at academic conferences to say this, but I think the target of many of these domestic programs, especially like the War on poverty. I think, by you know, some measurements, the people have become worse, you know, worse off as a result of all this expenditure and this sort of social science experimentation, you know that you see in this phase of government in the nineteen sixties, and of course when that this phase ended in the late sixties, we really, you know, I mean, we've tinkered with things since, but this big phase of sort of Civil Rights Act, of Voting Rights Act, and War on Poverty, I would argue we really haven't ever returned to that again, because I think even many Democrats.
17:03 Pat moynihan is an example, self describe liberal Democrat, longtime senator from New York, but became one of the really fiercest, I think, most reasonable critics of the policy that he helped to build in the nineteen sixties. So this kind of era of experimentation, whatever quite goes away, I don't think we've ever returned to and quite the same way that we saw in the nineteen sixties. You know, I'm kind of okay with experimentation and operating a little bit in the theoretical, but not to the point when you know, like you say that twenty percent or ten twenty percent, whatever you want to call of the fringe of any party takes over and next thing you know, they've hijacked the economy, They've they've hijacked history, they've hijacked everything that is good policy or good politics, you know, like where we are right now, I mean, we're in such chaos. It's like we've lost our moral our moral connection are moral anchorings? However, way you want to look at it, first, principles that we can look at and say, okay, look at we're missing the mark here consistently. Where did we make the wrong turn? How should we you know, come back and make some adjustments.
18:17 But when it comes to politics, it seems like it's near impossible, Luke, and especially right now when we're so argumentative. Well, I think you set it up very nicely there. I think like the sixties were at a time today looking ahead to the election of next year, when people have really lost faith in a lot of the nation's institutions exactly, whether that be the Congress itself at an all time low. I think both parties I think wish they had other options in terms of the top of their ticket in the next year. Not everyone, but a good number people have lost faith in higher education and what our universities are doing. K through twelve the national media, and we could make quite a list here of institutions that I would say bipartisan perhaps for different reasons on occasion, but where we really have lost faith in many of our nation's institutions. And I think that's why in nineteen sixty eight a figure like Graham, who's not in the ballot, not in public office, was able to serve in the role that he did, because I think when we lose faith in kind of our official institutions in the nation, that allows it's sort of an unofficial person to fill a role because people are searching, they're searching for exactly and they want a way forward. And we made it out of the nineteen sixties maybe stronger. Kind of we're still figuring out what happened during that decade. I think, well, but I wonder today, kind of where are the Grahams today? Where are those informal networks?
19:40 Are there Republicans talking to Democrats. They would never admit it publicly because compromise has become a dirty ward in politics for both sides. What makes compromise means selling out these days? But I wonder today, you know, where are those informal personal networks you know that will guide us out of this era. And it may take a number of years for us to look back this period and makes sense of it. Well, Uh, I guess my hope and faith, like yours, Luke, is that they are meeting maybe not in upfront and obvious Uh. You know, the mainstream media seems to be greatly distracted. Uh, and that that offers covering on both sides, which is kind of okay, I guess, but but you're right. I think we're missing, you know, a dynamic figure or numbers of figures. Because I thought myself, and having worked with the Billy Graham Association in the eighties, my thought was, when you know, doctor Graham was passing that, oh my god, you know, who's who is going to be the next doctor Graham? And the impression I had was that it wasn't going to be a doctor Graham, but there were going to be lots of doctor Graham's, lots of moral agents that are responding to these frustrating and chaotic times. And uh, you know, and maybe that's a good thing because you know, as we work through this u with experience defining preference is that you know, we need to understand that we're missing the mark. You've got a majority of Americans
21:12 say we're on the wrong track. Great observation. Okay, but let's understand what does the right track look like? Right? Well, I think Reverend Graham played a critical role during during the year, I mean the seventy years basically you know of his career because you can see, I mean, he was sort of he was very much a bipartisan figure and what a president told him generally did not leak on any substantial leak. This was a private pastoral relationship. And and you know, while we didn't know until very recently that he had he had documented some of these conversations. This was many years after the fact, when when these people are all deceased now, and I think he must have felt it was important for history to understand how some of these events really took place behind the scenes. And so it's and I don't you know, I don't know what's not it written down, And surely there are lots of conversations that we don't have a record of. That's the alst of the problemised sources. You don't know what's not there. But I think this is just a fascinating you know, I hope there are you know, more Billy Grahams in the future, because I think leaders on both sides of the aisle need people, you know, who aren't motivated primarily by partisan politics, and I think really have the best for the nation in mind. Well, you think about this great American idea and how it came to be. Uh, you know, you get John Winthrop envisioning America as this light on a shining hill, and some may say that that light has been dimmed a little bit. But I'm still hopeful because I believe that, you know, this
22:45 is a covenant relationship between God Almighty and the people. And though you know, we may refer to them as the silent majority at one part, especially during the sixties and seventies, and that, uh, they're still there, and they're there, and I think you're starting to see some demonstration of this because people are realizing that it can't be all about politics. That politics is supposed to be downstream the culture. But unfortunately what it's kind of been inverted a little bit the way I see it, Luke, I'm not sure if you see it the same way, but that it's uh, now we've got the culture downstream of politics, and and that's that's a bad formula because that has us at each other's throats. It ununites us, and it uh, you know, it has us constantly looking for a fight as opposed to, you know, being united and coming together for the common good. And and I think oftentimes the national media does it does us a disservice, you know.
23:51 I think they're a motivation of profit, and you know, social media adds, you know, have the effect of dividing us, you know, for the sake of profit. And I think if you his history though, I think can be a useful guide, you know, as long you know I should. I've said this before, but I'm a bit of a cynic. And when I see a new political book, I always wonder, you know, who's the author. You know, they have an agenda to exactly I do the same thing. It seems like, it seems like they often do. And think a close reader who knows the subject can figure that out pretty quickly. But you know, during the New Deal and the Depression, which was a terrible time now for my grandparents, you know, Franklin Roosevelt referred to it as the silent man, and then I become the forgotten man.
24:33 Was kind of the class classification of person who didn't look for handouts, who went to work, who went to church, provided for their family and paid taxes. That became kind of the silent majority, and then the late by the late nineteen sixties, that kind of then moved further, maybe to the mora on majority in the nineteen eighties, and then of course President Trump really capitalized again on that idea of the side of the majority. It's a slightly different composition of the group, but I think the concept is still the same that in our neighborhoods these days. You know, I'm guilty of not getting to know my neighbors as well as I probably should, and others in your audience are the same way. And I think there's still many millions of people. You know, we say things to each other on social media that, at least the way I was raised, we would never say to each other face to face, exactly. I think there are there's a core of millions of people while we vote Democrat or Republican, we go to this church or to no church. I think there is still a lot that binds us together as Americans, and the importance now of a figure who can help us to rediscover that and and most importantly, you know, learn how to how to have a discussion and to disagree but not be disagreeable. I think we've really lost that, you know, without without a doubt, because in that process where we have separated ourselves and thrown ourselves into our silos of choice, we really have rendered ourselves stupid. As Jordan peters And would say, because you're eliminating fifty percent of the population and brain trust, so to speak,
26:06 the cumulative intelligence of three hundred and fifty million people. I'll take that over a dozen any day. Uh, you know, because we can, you know, we can sharpen up our blades. We can you know, debate and advance our ideas accordingly, and we're all the better when you look, pat you know, you look back in history and you see where there is this collaboration of effort regardless of you know, color of skin, background, it's just you know, for the good of all concerned. My goodness, we move mountains, don't we. I still have a lot of faith in people. You know. My background is, you know, I was pretty much Northwestern Ohio, blue collar, lower middle class kid, first college, first generation college graduate in my immediate family. But I'll tell you something that that graduate school doesn't teach, and that's common sense and courtesy toward other people.
26:57 And so, you know, I think I think there is Again, we've lived in We've been in Austin, Texas area, the Midwest, the Washington, DC area, and now life has taken us on this adventure to southern California. And you know, wherever I go people might sound a little different and look a little different. There's a lot of good people still out there, right, and and and it's it's the question is, you know, how do we mobilize this and and and and use that as a guide, you know, of out of this chaotic era. I think it's going to happen. I think there is going to be that Billy Graham or there is going to be that person that captures this idea of the silent majority or the forgotten man, and we need to return to common sense and what works for the majority of people. Yeah, And as you say, it was interesting you mentioned Austin, Texas. I was just seeing the other day where these driverless cars have gone nuts in Austin. Did you see that? I did not see the latest one, but this is a this is a phenomena and a lot of these self driving car and the Tesla's and others that have these features. It's a fascinating idea, but I sure hope we can work the kinks out of them. Well we have to, I mean, running into each other, polls all that. The thing is hysterical, this bit of footage. The police pulled it over or thought it was pulling it over, and they go there and there's there's nobody there. Who can they ticket?
28:12 Well, I'm sure it raises constitutional issues about you know, a fifth Amendment, like facing your accuser and one of these cars hit you and I there's what recourse do you have? Yeah, I mean any excuse me for making a hard left on you. But when you mentioned Austin, I just all of a sudden I flashed on that and thought, boy, this is something that we have to work out. But you know, getting back to the situation of a free press and our First Amendment, this is where I believe that the free press, our national media, has disserved U, the Constitution and we the people, because their job and the reason that a free media is so protected and highly regarded, is so that they can hold accountable these institutions that are supposed to serve us, and unfortunately they've gotten as some would say in the business world inside of the bubble. And once you do that, you you have violated confidence, You've violated your brand. And this is what's lacking in these institutions, consistency, consistency that is aligned with the US Constitution. They've broken rank and this is this is all contributing to the chaoss that were realizing today. In my humble opinion, Luke No, I think you're right. You know, in the sixties it was a little different because all of the media were on the left. There really was no whether it be print or magazines, the dailies, the weeklies, you know,
29:45 people young people especially. There were three networks, you know, ABC, CBS, NBC, public television was kind of a new thing that was coming along, and they were all on one side. And then now you do have much broader, you know, proliferation across the political spectrum. But I think in a sense they all take the same approach. I mean, even those on the right sort of mimic the approaches on the left. And and you know, I remember something smart that we had secretary former Secretary of State Condo Lea's a Rights on our campus here in Orange County and Chapman last spring, and she said something that sort of challenged me personally. She said, you know, we all have our news feeds every day. Uh, and they probably know us better than we know ourselves in terms of our views.
30:26 And they say these articles are kind of promoted to us because they confirm our views. And she said, I make a point every day of trying to read at least one article that I know is going to make me angry because it's going to have a perspective different than mine. I've kind of taken that not as a challenge too, because you know, it's it's it's it's really important for us to understand our blind spots in our own thinking. And it's really I think immediate the media environment you describe, no matter where you land on the political spectrum, it's really easy to fall into a trap where that's that's you can't really see beyond that. Sometimes well you get conditioned. I mean it amazes me. I mean, we have an attorney general, Okay, he was just interviewed, he was just before Congress, and he didn't know who Victor Schokin was. You're an attorney general. You don't know who Victor Shokin is? Well, And I came away from that testimony with the idea that it's hard for me to swallow as kind of a Midwestern kid at heart, that there's not more cooperation with the White House on some of these matters. I mean, it's someone who studies the records of previous administrations, and here in the nineteen sixties, the White House is definitely involved on anything important that the DOJ does. That doesn't mean they're dictating it, but there's no question. And if you're the attorney general, you're definitely giving a heads up to your boss in the Oval office about what's going to happen. You don't want him or her to read that in the newspapers for the first time and be surprised. So, as I say, sometimes it's taken fifty five
32:00 years to kind of make more sense of nineteen sixty eight, I'm going to come back on your show in fifty five years to make sense of this current error. I hope it doesn't take that long, right, right, somebody who studies records of presidents. There's an awful lot in that testimony that was hard for me to swallow. Two. Yeah, exactly. Well, you know we know that under Obama's administration, his Attorney general was often referred to as his wingman. Uh, you know they moved away from that. You know, Donald Trump's wing man abandoned ship Fliftymagan on his own. That's a whole other story. But in this particular case with Garland, I mean, he may not directly take orders just in't like in the same way that Lois Learner may not have gotten a specific order to go after all these tea party organizations or these conservatives. But there was a wink wink and a nod nod, because after that message went out, Lois Learner went directly after all the conservative groups. And I maintained to this day, Luke that that has and has effect anywhere from ten to maybe a dozen voting cycles what she did.
33:14 And to this day, you know, these cheap party organization conservative groups have never been granted their tax exemption position, which they had every right to have. Well, and on a related subject, I remember after January sixth and the firestorm in the media and people were asking me, I had no inside knowledge of whatever was going on, but you know, what's your reaction and my reaction at the time, which I stand by today. Again, having studied the nineteen sixties and FBI infiltration of peace groups and anti war protesters when they don't underestimate what the government's capable when it's scared, when bureaucrats are scared. I said, I would be surprised if there are many, you know, convictions from January sixth, because I think it could take decades. We're going to find the government had pretty well infiltrated any that rally and those who had gone to the Capitol, and we're going to learn that the government was pretty well aware of what was going on, and that's going to make it hard for them to prosecute people. Well, but they're not having a problem prosecuting people well, even people who weren't there. I mean, look at the head of the Proud Boys. He wasn't even there in DC at the time, and he's been given the harshest sentence of twenty two years. Well, the lesson of the nineteen sixties and the Watergate era, I would say, is they can hand out the sentences and they'll be overturned on appeal.
34:37 Yes, and you know oftentimes in that first assessment, you know there is judicial overreach. Well, and the problem you have, particularly with Washington, DC, with ninety six percent of DC being liberal, a conservative, or anybody with that kind of perspective, I mean, you might as well just assume the position and uh and just get yourself on the skewer because you're done. And the idea of a fair trial if you're a conservative, you know, which is a constitutional right that we should all have exactly or not. It's just it's just it's it's just not depending on your politics. You know, there are pockets of the country where that's that's just not possible based on the judges, based on the jury pool. Well, and Luke, what do you think, I mean, do we get to some point where we finally just say, look at if we're going to have trials, and you really are, you know, you're supposed to have a trial of your peers, then you need to be in an area where your peers exist, not some area that is so one sided. Uh. You know, you know, for example, like you know you had on the other side, you had a Democrat attorney who was caught breaking the law, but because his his uh you know, his case was dealt with in DC pretty much got away with it. Hey, you know we're at we're getting into all kinds of controversy here, So I'll throw out another one. Okay, where in the world as President Trump get a fair trial? Yeah, exactly. And secondly,
36:09 what does a fair trial look like? Describe that for me? I don't know. I wish I had the answer. Well, and the unfortunate thing is it's going to come down, like you said, it'll go to appeal, and then it's finally going to end up where it probably maybe should have been prompted a long time ago, in the Supreme Court, and it's going to be a decision by maybe one or two judges, and then that still leaves this divided. Uh. You know, it's just amazing, you know, particularly when you bring up Donald Trump, I mean the Russian you know, collusion deal, which you know was false from the very beginning. The FBI knew it was false, they continued to pursue it. They got outside their lane, they violated their brand identity in terms of you know, justice and fairness, and they went after they turned into a political apparatus for the Democratic Party. And they've messed us all up ever since. Because even though they spent millions and millions of dollars to adjudicate this case, you know, a special prosecutor and everything they came up with Bubkis and the people still didn't believe it. They didn't believe it to such a degree. The Democrats said, well, it's not over, So now they're going to come up with another make believe story of why they should impeach Donald Trump. So now we're going to do it over a phone call. And the ironic thing is here, it's gone full circle. The phone call that they accuse President Trump of is evidenced by Joe Biden himself saying he did affect a quid pro quo
37:45 decision in holding out a billion dollars in order to fire the prosecutor that Merrick Garland didn't even know. So, I mean, this is absurd where we are right now, but this is today's politics. Well, and when you know, I think each time there's another federal charge or an impeachment talk, I think all they're doing is guaranteeing that Trump is the nominee well without a doubt, because it just it just continues to enlarge the spotlight on him, you know, and then when impeachment doesn't work, now it's state by state trying to disqualify him from the ballot. The latest thing here in California is that that calif dynamic controls the ballot, and we're going to remove him from the ballot. And as you say, I think all these things are going to be on the fast lane to the Supreme Court because these are these are not state issues. These are federal issues exactly. That are that are that are going to quickly exhaust any lower level of adjudication. And that's the only place they can go is a Supreme Court exactly. And and and we need the Supreme Court to really come in and preempt this, don't we look, I mean, because how long can we chew on this? This this is you know, disunifying, it's disturbing, uh, you know, discontinues.
38:59 And now at the end of twenty twenty four, we're going to end up with another twenty twenty election or a twenty sixteen election us against them. We don't believe in the results. I don't I don't know if America can live with another four years of this kind of wackiness questioning the results of a federal election. Well, and you know, to go back to my book title The Year That Broke Politics. What we're talking about is what politics looks like when it's broken exactly, when things don't work the way they should, right, And so really, though, what do you fall back on as an American in that time? And you fall back on it's it's the three, you know, the faith, the flag, and the family. Yes that there are millions of people who on both sides who say enough, you know, let's let's move on, right yea. They want to disengage from politics and go back. I call them first principles. We got to come back to first principles, the things that we all agree on. I don't care if you're a Democrat to carry your Republican independent whatever, But I think that if we all got in the room and said, hey, just like you said, the faith of family, uh and uh what was that you said?
40:09 Faith? Family and flag? And faith, family and flag, you get you get people in the room, and you'd probably get eighty percent easy right off the bat, that would agree with that. Yeah. I like, hey, let's just take all the best ideas wherever they come from. It doesn't matter who owns them or takes credit exactly. And you know, let's I mean, maybe maybe we don't need much in Washington. We can govern ourselves. Well, I think our founding fathers that that's what they intended. They intended to limit government as much as possible. But government cannot help itself. Humanity, I mean, we're human beings, were flawed, We make mistakes, and you know, I mean even the children of Israel here they have God Almighty is their king there say that's not good enough. We want an earthly king. I mean, you know, it's just this continuum of a repeat of history and a demonstration of uh, you know, of our frailty and ineffectiveness because nobody has all the goods Luke. But I will say again the lesson of history is, you know, we're going through the eye of the storm right now. And when you're in the eye of the storm, when you're in the valley, you know, you can't see beyond that it's dark. And you know, we got through the nineteen sixties.
41:21 We will get through this somehow or another, and we will be able with some personal professional distance, look back on us and it'll all make sense how we got through it. But I think that's part of the challenge right now, is that we can't quite see our way out of this. Yeah, it's the challenge at the same time, it's the hope, as you say, because when you look back historically, we've been here before. Uh, you know, we've been able to battle through. And I think, you know, because of the Constitution. I mean, here we are. We're not even a week away from Constitutional Day, which was less less Sunday. And I tell you, Luke, I encouraged our, our viewers and our audience, you know, leading into that day to you know, spend a moment. I mean, what are we talking? What four thousand words and the Constitution? What a beautiful document? Remind yourself of what our founding was all about and uncharacteristically uncharacteristic of the modern era. It's a document that's easily understood, right, I mean it's not. It's not eighty seven hundred pages of all kinds of godly gook and conflicts and language. It pretty much gives it straight up, doesn't it. No. I think what you describe there, eighty seven hundred pages of gobbled togo because about every bill passed by Congress these days, right, But that's the document our founding. Our founding documents were surprisingly simple, jargon free, you know, written and fairly plain language.
42:45 And I think you know, it would serve all Americans, not just those you know sitting for a citizenship exam, to understand a little more what's actually in there, well without a doubt. And the thing is is that the people you know are elected officials, Congress senators, they're voting on legislation they haven't read. They're counting on their staff to have read it. And probably if you examine the staff, you'd probably find that there was a small percentage of them that actually read the bill. Well, my first job out of college at twenty three was in the Speaker's office, and then I worked on a committee on the House side, and it's been that's spent twenty years. That was sort of the end of Clinton beginning of Bush forty three administration.
43:25 But I saw that then. I mean, you know that votes today will start at say two o'clock, and you're still waiting for the draft of some two thousand page budget bill. Uh. And even if you had somehow the time to speed read that, questions a curney while you're reading, how did this get in here? You see that you see the fingerprints of this lobbyist or that pressured group, you know, getting their few lines. You know, in the final bill, and so even if you had time to read it, you know, you couldn't sort through those kinds of details and figure out, you know, what what is it, What's what's the effect of this exactly became almost a joke that we don't know what's in it until we pass it. Well, yeah, Nancy Pelosi made that clear. And of course then the administrative state gets their hands on it, and uh, and of course the escape for you know, our elected officials is going, well, you know, it's it's that bureaucratic administrative state. It's their fault.
44:19 You know, we pass the bill, but you know that's the way they interpreted. So now here we are, you know, the forgotten men and woman, you might say, And we're subjected to this silliness until there's enough complaining or that, you know, it maybe ends up after appeal after appeal and in the Supreme Court and its squared away. But meanwhile we're three five years of paying down the road. Well, I think it was Milton Friedman who said something like, there's nothing so permanent as a temporary government program, because you know, it's awfully easy to start some new initiative today. But once you start paying salaries and people buy homes in Washington, DC, and you're paying pensions and retirement plans. It's very difficult to cut government.
45:02 And so even if you're not really a believer in the idea of the deep state, uh, you know that's I don't think that's a term that I use once in this book. I think you can. It's easy to see though, that government begins after a while to serve its own purpose, that it always grows, it doesn't want to shrink, and it's it's a powerful kind of own economy and property market in the Washington, DC area, And so, you know, it is enormously difficult. I think Democrats, it's always the answer is always growing government. Republicans is always shrinking it. And I think you know those there's really automatic tension I think nowadays almost any time for a Republican who gets into office, because it's very difficult to cut government.
45:44 Well, look, you imagine, how would you like to be elected president and you got sixty days to hire thousands of people in your administration? How do you do that? Well? And all that can be undone the first day. If one out of a hundred senators says nope, not going to consider any of your nominees. And it used to be, you know, not that long ago, where you give deference to a to a new president, they have a hundred days. They kind of have a period where we give them a chance to try out some other ideas. I think the one hundred days nowadays has become I don't even know if they have a hundred minutes until the first verdict of their presidency has already been written by the media. Well, I think Donald Trump it was seconds. Yeah, I don't think it was in the back in November before he raised his hand exactly.
46:29 So now it's uh, well, here it is. I mean again, this all speaks of what you talk about in your book, that it is broken. And like you, I believe in the American people. I believe in the resolve of the American people, their commitment to the American dream, regardless of the open borders that we're experiencing. Uh, the you know, the obvious corruption that seems to be running rampant in our government, the compromise of the Three Letter agencies to such a degree that we've lost faith in them. Uh you know, but at some point, like you said, something has got to give, and I believe that what always comes out on the bright side of it is the American people. I think you're exactly right, and that's exactly how I would conclude it. You know, while the pendulum of politics never stops moving, some push it right, some push it left.
47:22 But it's the American people who want to push it towards the center and who ultimately decide kind of where that center is and where common sense exists, where we can build bridges across the aisle to people who are different than we are. But I think history, history is a history such a powerful guide, and it is what I try to do in this book because you know, again, I'm writing these four very different sides where you know that one side could read their part of the book and I think basically recognize what's in here exactly. And my goal is not to serve one political interest. It's it's to reach as many people as possible. I think understanding our history and how we got here, Like the wars of the nineteen sixties, those culture and political wars, they help us, they give us tools to work through our era today. Well, Luke, we've got about a minute left here.
48:13 Your book. The year that broke politics that still resonates today in the Year that Broke politics, collusion and chaos in the presidential election of nineteen sixty eight. I'm going to let you give a final summary and remind people how they can get your get their hands on your book. Sure, well again, it's been a great pleasure. The easiest way to track me down. I love to hear from people. I get questions just about every day. I would say, Luke Nicktar dot com, l U K E n I c H t er dot com, and you can find out more about me and reach out, whether you agree with me or whether you disagree with me. My point is not to have the final word, because there is no final word in history. It's really to start a conversation and a dialogue, which is what we need as much about today about things going on today as we do about history itself. Exactly. Well, Luke, again, thank you so much for being with us. Appreciated you. Congratulations on the book The Year that Broke Politics. Luke Nicker has been our guest for more information and to be a part of this mighty movement to return to God and save our country. Go to Bill Martinez Show dot com. May God bless you and keep you, and make his face shine upon you. May He be gracious unto you and give you peace. Go and be blessed to bless others.
49:28 Thank you so much for being with us. Have a great day.
iHeartRadio
Spotify
Amazon Music
Pandora
Audible
Apple Podcasts
Spreaker
Podchaser
Podcast Addict
Castbox
Goodpods
PlayerFM
Podverse
Podyssey
Castro
RadioPublic
Overcast
RSS Feed
YouTube