Bill Martinez Live
Aug. 4, 2023

Is Social Justice Just

Is Social Justice Just
Is Social Justice Just
Bill Martinez Live
Is Social Justice Just

In this new book, Is Social Justice Just, twenty-one accomplished academics seek to answer this question. In a world of partisanship, hysteria, maliciousness, and good intentions attached to hellish outcomes, this landmark book enters the public...

In this new book, Is Social Justice Just, twenty-one accomplished academics seek to answer this question. In a world of partisanship, hysteria, maliciousness, and good intentions attached to hellish outcomes, this landmark book enters the public discourse at a critical time. Robert Whaples, The Senior Fellow at the Independent Institute, Co-Editor and Managing Editor of The Independent Review, and a Professor of Economics at Wake Forest University discusses.

The Bill Martinez Show is broadcast live Monday - Friday at 1PM ET.

The Bill Martinez TV Show is viewed on Talk 4 TV (www.talk4tv.com).

The Bill Martinez Radio Show is broadcast on W4CY Radio (www.w4cy.com) part of Talk 4 Radio (www.talk4radio.com) on the Talk 4 Media Network (www.talk4media.com).

The Bill Martinez Podcast is also available on Talk 4 Podcasting (www.talk4podcasting.com), iHeartRadio, Amazon Music, Pandora, Spotify, Audible, and over 100 other podcast outlets.
Transcript

0:12 The topics and opinions expressed in the following show are solely those of the hosts and their guests, and not those of W FORCY Radio. It's employees are affiliates. We make no recommendations or endorsements for radio show, program services, or products mentioned on air or on our web. No liability, explicit or implied shall be extended to W FORCY Radio. It's employees are affiliates. Any questions or comments should be directed to those show hosts. Thank you for choosing W FORCY Radio. Well, welcome to the Bill Martinez Show. Great to have you with us, and we're gonna take on you know, rather controversial subject. It's one that comes up, especially at these days, is social justice. Just think about that, right, probably you don't think very long, you know, you just put out put that out there, and everybody has an idea. Well, our next guest, who's going to be joining us in just a moment. Robert Robert Wables has tackled, you know, that topic along with twenty one accomplished academics that do their best to answer this question. I say do their best. I understand, you know, you know the fact that it's out there is so that we can talk about it, but let's talk about it in an enlightenment space, so to speak, that it's not just so emotional that we're aggrieved and we're victims, but that

1:42 we're able to really have a benefiting, uh flourishing conversation about the topic. Is social justice? Just in this world of partisanship, hysteria, maliciousness, good intentions attached to hellish outcomes. This incredible book that's becoming a landmark book enters the public discourse at a critical time. Robert Waples he's a senior Fellow at the Independent Institute, co editor managing editor of The Independent Review, and professor of economics at Wake Forest University. Robert, Welcome to shew. Good to have you with us. Thank you for having me on. Well, thank you for tackling this topic. When you first came up with this idea, did you have an argument with yourself? No. The idea is that, you know, there've been all these discussions about social justice. It's it's a hot topic, but it's yes, there's so much disagreement, and I think our thought was that if we could kind of get back to first principles what is justice and then go from that to what is social justice? We could actually kind of restart the conversation and maybe get a moving in the right direction. Right. Well, you know when I say that you're arguing with yourself, I just this is such a heavy lip. I mean, this is a you know that you may you may doubt yourself. I know, sometimes you get these godlike ideas and you think, oh, you know, God, you're having fun with me, aren't you, Because you're talking to

3:15 the wrong guy. You know, I'm not the ombre here that's going to build the art because I know nothing about building arcs. You know what I'm saying. That's that was my starting point on this is that I think people are by and large of goodwill, right, And I open my introduction to the book. I open also the chapter that I wrote, the final chapter in the book by saying that we all hunger and thirst right for a just world, and we work constantly in ways great and small to bring about justice. So let's have people with kind of good faith, good intentions talking about it. Yeah. Yeah, I think what you're saying, and I agree with you this. My believes the same thing is that we're wired this way.

4:02 You know, We're wired with a conscience. We know when we do good, we know we do bad. You know, it's when we get confused that things get really squirrely. And I understand that because right now things seem a little squirrely. So yeah, if you look at it, you know, you mentioned the word social justice to a lot of people, you get so many different reactions. There's some people sometimes called social justice warriors or something, who see social justice that term is just a sincere attempt to right wrongs, to pull down oppressors, to help the underdog, to do that kind of thing. But then people will respond to them like, but how do the ideas you just came up with actually help the underdog? And why do you see oppressors everywhere? Okay? And so there's a lot of people on the other side, or just say, you know what, so much of this social justice talk is about it's just line in your own pockets, right, rent seeking talking up a problem and then you know, I can get some money, I can get some prestigia. So there's so much baggage in it, and it's been used as, like one of our authors says, as a cudgel, right, yes, people over the head. The problem with the term justice is that implies it. If there's an injustice, you're pretty much obliged to do something about it. And would that then involve the state, and bringing the state into things so often ends up just blowing up, even sincere attempts to solve this, you know, with the coercive power of government can so often make things worse, exactly without a doubt.

5:34 You know. I like what you said about, you know, going to first principles, because we need to agree on what the standard is. What is the standard? What is social justice? We start with kind of the old fashioned definition of justice, which goes back to Aristotle, goes to Thomas the Quintas. People like that. It's the constant and perpetual will to render to each what is due to him. Right and our day to day going about life, making contracts with other people, you know, talking about how to run our families. That's what we have in mind, the constant, perpetual will to render each to each person what's due to them. What do I owe you? You know, if you go beyond that, that's like benevolence or you know, but just as itself requires, did you give people at least what's what is due to them. So then social justice to put that word in front, what does that mean? We interpret it as being Okay, well, now let's think about the rules of the game, our laws, social norms, those kinds of things that will promote every person getting what is due to him. And we take our model of a person as being one that the words I use in the book, recognizes each person as unique, unrepeatable, worthy of dignity, endowed with the ability to direct his or her own life without harming other people, and noble enough to care deeply

7:08 about the well being of others. That's our starting point, that's my starting point, right that. I mean, we're endowed with this ability. I think the endowment comes, you know, direct from above. I believe with you, and we're endowed with that. That's why we were creative, you know, to to yeah, and so, but it's you know, we just don't think about, you know, how to run our own lives without harming other people. Were also, as I said, they're noble enough to care about other people and want them to flourish along with us. So how do you build a system based on that? I think most of the authors in the book and I would agree it's really a bottom up thing. It begins with just the way we treat each other. Uh say, today will be that change that you want to seeing others right exactly? Yeah, And weighs great. And you make such a clear point here that we are in doubt. We're prewired with this because what you're talking about, I'd say the majority of Americans get it. They their lives are operating this way. Even though we may see things chaotically on the rise, it's still in the minority.

8:20 And this is what gives me faith, Robert, in the American people. I think the world at large, as you said, for the most part, people think nobly. They want to do right for themselves, especially people for faith. In faith, people in faith want to do right by God and right to their neighbors. That is a driven principle that you know gets us from one day to the next. And sometimes we fail, we fall short, We get that, but because this is a guiding principle, we come back to it. Like you said, we constantly, We constantly return to first principles and measure our behavior against first principles. And because when things are so disruptive and we feel like wait minute, social justice isn't just okay, what why are we there? What what is telling us that it's unjust? Right? Exactly? And so we need to have firm principles.

9:22 And you know, for a Christian, I think that would go back to those ten commandments that we've heard about and and all the things that then grow up out of that, and you know, the things that Jesus preached in the Sermon on the Mountain that you know, he talked about during his entire ministry and then suffered and died for my sins, so that you know, we could uh, yeah, we could overcome all the evil and the temptations of the world. And so to me, that's where you really have to get started. Yeah. So so we get started there. We have a defining point, a standard, our north star that we we understanding, we agree on, and this is an individual decision and revelation. Right. And then you go and you live life in the marketplace, and then you run into people that aren't necessarily interested in justice. They're just interested in having it their way. I was I was on a radio talk show a couple of weeks ago talking about this, and the host I believe he meant this in all seriousness. He said, all I really care about is me, and I thought to myself, in fact, I think I bluted out. I doubt that's really true, you know, but we do run into people that all they care about is them, and there are ways that when you deal with people like that, it can it can, it can work out.

10:41 Right. The marketplace is especially designed to do that. You deal with often complete strangers. And what does standard economics tell us, Right, there's a demand curve, there's this apply curve. There's a price that comes out, and you know what, it's a win win situation. Students, this intro right off the bat, right, there's consumer surplus, there's producers surplus. It's actually a win win situation both actually when they're not coerced to do things, when there's not fraud or theft or something like that, that's how it works out. And so this we've harnessed that institution so well in our society.

11:22 Of course, it doesn't solve every problem. We've harnessed it so well to tap the energy the innovativeness, right of these inventors and entrepreneurs, but you know, just not the famous ones, all of us, which hardness that so well that we have created genuine human prosperity. I wrote a study last year where I looked at where do the poorest five percent of Americans fit into the overall income distribution? Okay, so by definition, of course, five percent of Americans are to be at the fifth percentile amongst Americans. They're also at the sixty ninth percentile among all people living in the world. But in the paper, I then went back and looked at estimates from economic historians and demographers, like all the people who've ever lived, where did the poorest five percent of Americans fit in that income distribution? And discovered it's about it.

12:22 The ninety fifth percentile, the ninety percentile, our poorest because of the system that we have built, just as us trading with each other, mostly self interested, has allowed the poorest people to be among the richest all time. I am so grateful that I live in that situation, you know, materially that I don't face the sheer hunger and malnutrition and lack of good clothing and shelter and everything that most people have struggled with throughout most of human history. We're pretty we've done a pretty good job at Wibano's absolute poverty. Wow. Thank you God for that men, and let's not thive that away and then not let's not also then worship Mondment. Right, let's not think that that was the end of the whole thing. But that's not It's all about and that's a stepping off point, right, a springboard for us. And then too, you know, rise to that nobility in which God made it right, help and help us hold it in proper perspective to where it's advantageous for all concerned. Robert Wakeles is whether it's a senior fellow at the Independent Institute, co editor managing editor of The Independent Review, and a professor at economics at wake Forest University. We're talking about his new book is Social Justice just uh he edited it. He was blessed and we're blessed as a result to bring together twenty one accomplished academics. Robert, how did you do this?

13:50 How did you get uh, you know, these network of willing academics to participate in answering this heavy question. We were actually very lucky. The book is published by the Independent Institute and the set of the papers in it were published in The Independent Review, which I edit. But to encourage people to contribute an anonymous donor I do not know who this person is put up ten thousand dollars for the best essay, and that's right, did some pretty good? Actually? Wow? Yeah, so Jim Oddison, who's chapters in the book, he's of professor, a philosopher teaching in the business school over at Notre Dame. He won the ten thousand bugs. Very very nice.

14:33 But did you take you out to dinner at least? Well, you know i've happened in a while. No, he didn't. He didn't take me out to dinner. Well, well we'll dinner. Shame him here on the TV show. Okay, I'm not actually the kind of guy that says, hey take me out. Of course, of course you're not. But no, I mean, hey, look at it's uh, you know, so we we didn't get a lot of people. And you can see there from actually from number of countries around the world. There's economists, there's philosophers, there's historians, there's legal scholars, there's people from like, you know, all sorts of different backgrounds, and they you know, they're all coming from different starting points and they all have kind of they've been thinking about these ideas for a long time, and so we've kind of galvanized them to think about it, and I think we got some excellent chapters, and Jim's chapter in particular, you know, I'll talk about a little bit. He's a Smith scholar and Adam Smith's scholar, and he basically argues, you know, we need to get back to Smithian principles in doing this. And so what did Smith advocate in his book The Theory of Moral Sentiments and then later in the Wealth of Nations. Basically that cooperation is the key. We need to set up institutions that allow people to cooperate with each other, and we need an authority collectively to make sure that people's the three p's and people's persons, property and promises are protected. Right. If you set that system up, you will see prosperity emerge. And it was happening at the time Smith was writing,

16:07 and you can see places around the world where it's just happened, like within a generation. Think about Hong Kong, think about Singapore. You know, people living there largely from China, but now they're put in a new setting, not under the old Chinese imperial system or communist system later, but in the kind of same kind of system. Adam Smith was in actually the British teaple system and what happened They started trading with each other and they just got more and more and more prosperous, and so it didn't make them perfect people, but it sure did solve that fundamental human problem. Yeah, don't you love system I love systems, you know, because they're they're easy to measure, you see results from it, you can adjust it. And what he addresses here to me, I just in my latter years of life, I've just come to appreciate it because it's like, you know, I'll talk about God's infrastructure at times, Robert, and God's infrastructure is so perfect.

17:07 It's designed too. By the way, for some people this may be a little disturbing. Brain it does accommodate and handle climate change. Okay, just I just want you to know, because God Almighty is in charge, He's got that all figured out. And that doesn't mean that we don't have a role to play. I'm not saying that. But I'm just saying is that God's infrastructure is there. It's in place, and it's quite evident and obvious, as obvious as is the law gravity that when you divide his infrastructure. You're you're gonna have consequences and it could be very painful, right, Yeah, So I genuinely believe in the idea of divine providence. You know, God said this system up for us so that we would well, I mean, he designed us so they will actually get back home in the long run, back up. Well, he wants he wants it, he wants it to go well with us. I mean that's what he told Jane, right, if you do right, will it not go well for you? And that that warning echo has been echoing through the millennium since. Yeah, So, I mean he he, I don't think made us to you know, be living a life like an animal or living. He made us in his own image and life this and you know, I think that includes us prospering, but of course then not worshiping our very own prosperity, which is a problem that I see you know, so often welling up. That's to me, the biggest challenge going forward for humanity right in the old days was how to live with all that absolute poverty and all that scarcity. We'll always have

18:41 scarcity with us, but it's sure is binding a lot less. And now it's like, how do we live with this prosperity and actually lead flourishing lives. We've seen, you know, all sorts of problems in American society, Western society, wealthy country society, or you know, we just are still thinking in kind of not thinking about the big picture and and just spinning our wheels and not and not putting these great games to good news. Right, little sidebar here. I don't know if you've seen this story that's going around about this guy that had a what he spent twelve thousand dollars to make himself into a dog, a collie. Have you seen this? No, I'm I am very glad I have none. O. It's it's a little bizarre.

19:26 I mean, people are having fun with this. Uh but you say, God designed this not to go live like animals. But then you get some people that have their own ideas, and I mean it's amazing. You know, he's created this outfit and he looks like a collie and they showed him the other day like he went out for his first walk, and I mean, the human condition is quite curious. We got to go to break. We've got more from Robert Waples. His book is Social Justice. Just stay with us, President Biden recently released a massive six trillion dollar budget, the largest budget in US history. And guests, who pays the bill, that's right, you, the American taxpayer. American citizens and business owners will be paying more taxes, that's a fact. And if you owe back taxes, they will be coming after you to collect payments. In fact, President Biden also hired thousands more IRS agents to go after you. If you've got a letter from the IRS and you know you owe back taxes or you haven't filed in years, don't put your head in the sand. Call us today.

20:45 We've saved our customers millions of tax dollars. One quick, free phone call will show you how we can reduce your past tax bill and save you thousands guaranteed, or you pay nothing. Call now eight hundred nine three two one five nine seven eight hundred nine three two one five nine seven. That's eight hundred nine three two fifteen ninety seven paid for by the tax helpline. Has your heater or air conditioner busted, appliance, broken, computer crashed, then you need an AARW home warranty. Home system and appliance repairs and replacements can cause stress and cost you thousands of dollars per year. With an A plus BBB rating and a top rated home warranty company on Consumer Affairs and trust Pilot, AARW Home provides superior service featuring the industry's lowest service call fee.

21:36 AARW Home has warranty plans that cover your kitchen and laundry appliances, heating and air conditioning systems, electrical and plumbing systems, and much more. Call eight hundred five five nine seven five six two to customize your plan. Plus, AARW has partnered with a Jurian to protect your new and used tablets, laptops, TV's, and other home tech from accidental damage and wear and tear. All plans come with a thirty day money back guarantee. Call eight hundred five five nine seven five six two. How would you like to save money on nearly all your prescription drugs? We've set up a special toll free number for the RX Outreach Program. They're a nonprofit company whose mission it is to make prescription drugs more affordable to the masses. They don't take insurance, and in many cases, your prescriptions are even cheaper than your copays. They carry thousands of different prescription drugs, so whatever you're taking, there's a good chance they have it. No coupons are required, and this is not a discount card.

22:33 It is pure savings on your prescription drugs. They specialize in generic meds for any chronic health needs you have. Call with your prescription and find out for free how little you can pay for your prescription drugs. Remember, we don't take insurance, so call right now. Eight hundred seven O five six five eight one eight hundred seven O five six five eight one eight hundred seven O five six five eight one. Hey, welcome back. Bill Martinez.

23:14 Here. Robert Waples is with us. We're talking about his book is social Justice just He had to take a little walk and think about somebody being dressed up and paying twelve thousand dollars to create an outfit for themselves to become a dog. Again, the human condition being what it is. I'm going to read this. It's from the jacket of the book. In the pages of the book, twenty one accomplished academics seek to do justice to social justice. Inequality exists, and it obviously causes riffs and societies, but it's not obvious how the government should address those rifts, or if they should do it at all, that you know, have we forgotten that perhaps more efficient power of personal choice and the corollary obligation to serve our neighbors, to make our society more humane? Uh? You know, Robert, you suggested as much as that, when we're allowed to be free human beings, it's amazing how the economy, within the design that God has established for us, it works itself out if it's allowed. But when you get government that comes in and they throw money at it, and they, you know, in a sense, they interrupt and disrupt what God has established, the creating more problems than what we began with. You have shown the cover of the book several times and it's a striking picture. It's you know, it's supposed to be justice being

24:45 blind with the scales, but this justice is speaking out from underneath that little blindfold kind of built things into one side or the other, and that's that's what we can't have. And our government does that in a number of ways. And so the book is i'll say, a sober warning that you know, even honest attempts to involve the state and it's coerced redistribution can rapidly turn into just rent seeking, as economists call it, trying to get your own cut. But the book also includes a number of calls to stamp out unwarranted privileges that are currently in the system. So there is chrony capitalism. There are firms out there that have gotten there. Much of their profits come from just having friends in the government. There have been some big corporate bailouts and that kind of stuff. You had bail one guy out, and then everybody else expects you to do it. They take bigger risk, and the next bailout's got to be even bigger. We gotta nip this, We gotta prune this problem back, We gotta get rid of it. We need to dismantle barriers to entry so that people can take their talents and bring them to other people. Right, we restrain the supply side in so many different ways.

25:56 You know, Occupational licensing is one of the things that's talked about several times in the book. Here are people that you know have these skills, but they don't They haven't checked off the right boxes, so they don't have whatever, you know, license they need from the government. What does that do in simple economics, I would tell my students that that shifts the supply curve in and drives the price up, and so those special insiders get bigger profits than the other way, and the customer gets ripped off in the process, and those outsiders who can't jump through those hoops, they're left out in the cold. They can't even exactly saw off the first rung on the ladder to success, as they say, right, yeah, well, of course we're seeing a lot of this right now with you know, the Hunter Biden case.

26:38 What's being revealed. Devin Archer had an interesting interview with Tucker Carlson the other night, and I think people are waking up and realizing, I mean, at least I mean going, that's right, those guys in the Beltway, what are they selling. It's not like they got a widget, it's not that they're doing a hotdog stand or something like that. They're they're just they're selling their connect their connections. Yeah, right, exactly, And that's that is the kind of thing that I think everybody agrees we need to stamp out, and so we've got to figure out ways to do it. It's really hard to do it, right. I don't know if you've heard of the economist Manser Olsen. He wrote this very influential book, The Logic of Collective Action. And so the whole problem is this, think about it like a tariff. I always talk about the sugar tariff in class. And there's this one family that owns a lot of sugar businesses, and then there's a cooperative down in Florida of sugar growers, and together they're like half the market.

27:41 And so if they lobby and they get some tariff increased, boy do they profit from it. It's you know, it's going to profit them to lobby, and they lobby both parties, they do all that kind of stuff. They ended up winning it. You know, estimates like a billion and a half extra knowledge for the profit for the industry. We consumers have to pay more and we lose more than they went. So we lose like about three billion dollars. But you divide that by the population of the US and it's like less than ten dollars per person. And so we don't get together with pitchforks and torture go down the Capitol Hill and say get rid of this bad law. They're organized and we're disorganized, right, and so what we need is actually more groups I think, like the one that you know that I edit the journal for the Independent Institute that are fighting the good fight for for the consumer, that are fighting the good fight for the people not in the special interest out there explaining what they're doing and how you know, they're taking advantage of everybody else. And we need to make it so that it's just embarrassing that you would take some kind of you know, cut from some from a special interest. Well, well the dealers are also, I mean when you talk to them sometimes they you say, well is that legal, and it's you know, and it's it almost becomes an ethical issue. Well it's kind of legal, Well is it ethical? Well, you know, you start getting into those gray areas. So again going back to what we first talked about first principles. See, we haven't defined first principles. If

29:12 first principles are defined, then we understand that insider trading is something that shouldn't be taking place. But the legislators have been able to do an end around and still managed to do insider trading though, I think what four or five years ago, after an investigation, they said, okay, well we got found out, so we better back off a little bit. And they backed off I think maybe for a couple of years, and they came back with a vengeance because they had to make up for the two years that they lost. Right. I think sunshine is, as they say, a very powerful disinfectant. Right. And so yeah, we know, and there are organizations out there, but it's also our job. We've got to pay attention.

29:55 There's a concept in economics called rational ignorance, and we, we voters are just rationally ignorant about those things because you know, it's costly to get this information. Was the benefit of us having it tiny, So we don't get much of the information, and you know, we go off and read a book or watch a baseball game or a batch of show or something like that instead of paying attention. And that's how they're they're able to get to that equilibrium where they can get away with with all of this stuff. So it's one of those almost intractable problems that you just need to work relentlessly at stamping it out. And the first step is to just get up and say it's wrong. It's exactly doing it. Yeah, we don't have enough talking about you know, it's just wrong that you're doing that. Well, now, We've got you know, politicians and leaders and whatever all over the political spectrum who do outrageous things and it's just getting you know, so that the standard of wrong, you know, standard of what they're going to do next is just getting you know, more and more out. Yeah, yeah, why are you picking on me? That other guy's doing worse than I am.

31:03 But you know, to your point, I like whatever Dickerson said, you know back in the days when it was a million dollars that I think you may have said it's a billion here, a billion there before you know what, you're talking about a lot of money, and you know, this is where we're at. We're thirty two and a half trillion dollars in debt and we're moving in the wrong direction, and especially with interest prices or interests uh increasing. Uh, we're what do we have about half half trillion? Uh? In terms of managing the debt service right off the top, I mean we're going to be approxritingillar it a lot of the debts kind of short terms. So once all the debt kind of has to roll over at the new higher interest rates, think about it. Uh, let's say five percent interest on thirty plus trillion dollars. You know, that's that's a trillion and a half dollars. That starts to crowd out things that can be you know, the government has some roles in the economy and that it should be doing and focusing on those things instead of us just always being so shortsighted that you know, we keep kicking this can down the road, as they say, and this never let's let the next generation deal with it. And there's another problem, and it's not when we really address in the book. I wrote an op ed piece not too long ago, it was actually published on on Father's Day and National Review online about how we're running out of kids. You know, people just are not having children anymore for whatever reason when they do that.

32:37 So it's not just the Chinese, right, yeah, it's not just them, it's us. The people just seem to exaggerate the costs of having children, raising children, and especially minimizing the benefits. This is like the greatest thing that happened to me in my life, becoming you know, getting married to a beautiful woman, having five beautiful children with them, right, it's a transformative experience. We've got to explain that other people having children is the greatest thing. And if we don't, not only will that make our lives worse, but it'll make those people who do have children's lives worse and their own lives when they're older because our population will shrink. World's population will probably start shrinking during my lifetime. And when it starts shrinking and we're this deep in debt, who's going to be able to pay off that debt?

33:30 The tax levels are going to have to go through the room, and you know we will will end up if that all plays out, being like Argentina or something like that. Well, what's so scarier about to me is the psychological impact that this has. I mean, you're you're going to have a lot of unhappy campers. Yes, I mean the joys of parenthood will will be lost. But then I have a colleague who's from China and the northern part of China that has the lowest fertility rates. And she's an only child, okay, and her parents were only child and she's she's a girl and the only child, she's lucky to survive. Well, she's a miracle.

34:10 And so you know her parents were only children too. Given China's policies, that means that not only does she not have a brother or sister, she doesn't have uncle, aunts or cousins as well. Imagine living in a world like that. And so she's actually she just had a baby a few months ago. And so you know, I visited her class one time. She's a junior colleague, and she was talking. The example she was giving in class was some data she collected amongst the students, like how many siblings you have and how happy you are. And she found with the sample of students that the more siblings you had, the happier, the happier you were. We are designed, I think, to be very social people like that.

34:52 Yeah, you think, I think so. You know, that's when we go with the design. I think, well, that's great application here we've got to go to break Robert waples Can continues with us. The senior fellow at the Independent Institute is social justice. Just stay with us. This radio commercial was made to convince you to stop speeding. We can't use siren sound effects on the radio, so we'll use other equally jarring sound effects to get your attention, like telling you that whether you drive a little over the speed limit or a lot, you can crash. Just the same. You could hurt yourself or worse others. I'm at the scene of the collision and the damage you cause will be beyond repair. See, we didn't have to use crash or siren sounds. After all, speeding catches up with you. Brought to you by NITSA. Hi. I'm Ronnie Deutsche And if you or your business own money to the IRS, I've got great news for you. Tax laws have changed. Billions of dollars are earmarked for IRS fresh dart programs.

36:00 If you qualify, you can literally save tens of thousands of dollars. Listen, I know what you're going through. Call on me if you want to speak with a tax attorney or tax professional. Four free eight hundred two four seven one four nine eight. How would you like to save money on nearly all your prescription drugs? We've set up a special toll free number for the RX Outreach Program. They're a nonprofit company whose mission it is to make prescription drugs more affordable to the masses. They don't take insurance, and in many cases your prescriptions are even cheaper than your co pays. They carry thousands of different prescription drugs, so whatever you're taking there's a good chance they have it. No coupons are required, and this is not a discount card. It is pure savings on your prescription drugs. They specialize in generic meds for any chronic health needs you have. Call with your prescription and find out for free how little you can pay for your prescription drugs. Remember we don't take insurance, so call right now. Eight hundred seven O five six five eight one.

37:00 Eight hundred seven O five six five eight one eight hundred seven O five six five eight one. How would you like to get high speed internet for your home for less than two dollars a day? That's right, For about fifty bucks a month, you'll get lightning fast internet. Are you paying less than fifty bucks a month right now for your internet? Then called whole home and connect right now for blazing fast internet at fifty bucks a month with no price increases, no hidden fees, no contracts, no upfront costs, no equipment fees. It's a great deal. And guess what, you can try it for fifteen days. If you don't like it, you get your money back. But you're gonna love it, and you're gonna love the price Internet for your home for fifty bucks a month. That's less than two bucks a day, plus no contracts, no upfront costs, no equipment fees, and our fifteen day guarantee call now eight hundred six nine nine three five eight eight hundred six nine nine three five eight eight hundred and six nine nine three five eight. Well, if you find yourself asking is social justice just, it's a good reason to get your hands on this book. Take advantage of the insight of twenty one academics who have come to gather here to address this heavy

38:30 topic because there's so much noise, I believe misunderstanding about social justice, first of all justices. Robert Wapel started out with, and then you bring in the idea of social justice and it may color your perspective just a little bit, but that's okay, there's nothing wrong with it. But we need to have this conversation in the light of day, not in silos or in ideological fixed corner. You know, Robert, I think it's quite interesting. You have one of my favorite philosophers, and Jordan Peterson, doing the forward of the book on the Narcissists of compassion. Explain that to our audience. Yeah, So he draws on Nietzsche the Philosopher and talks about how there's this spider there that basically I kind of think of the spider, you know, and learn of the rings she loves. Right, they're gonna get you, but basically convinces you that what's right is wrong and what's wrong is right. Here's here's a quote that I give in the introduction that I think captures a bunch of what Jordan says in his preface to the book Thomas Soul, you know, the economist Thomas. He says that envy once used to be one of the seven deadly sins before it became one of the most admired virtues under his new name, social Justice, that what drives so much of the social justice

40:04 agenda is sheer envy for other people's success. And we were talking about the chapter by Jim Modison. What he says we need to do is distinguish outcomes from three different sources. Right. One source of outcomes is just luck, and we all like a certain amount of luck. We don't want everything to be based on luck. But then the second source is decisions that we've made that we're entitled to make. And then the third source of outcomes is decisions we've made that we're not entitled to make. We need to focus on the third thing we need to focus on, you know, getting rid of chrony capitalism, that kind of stuff. Decisions people are making that they're not really entitled to make, allow a certain amount of luck, and focus on, you know, just decisions that people make that they're entitled to make, if they are entitled to make those decisions, and then we can't really second second judge it just because we don't like the way it ended up happening. Didn't win, but you know, there were the rules. We agreed that those rules were fair and and that's that's the way the game ended up. He's got a really good example. He uses it like this guy who's dating this girl, he's about to pop the big question, and then she meets this other guy that she likes even more, and it's like, is he entitled to something? No, it was. It was darned unlucky that that happened to him. But made a contract him, you know whatever, he's just and so the same thing like then for a store, there's a store and you were going there all the time. You love the store. A coffee shop and then another one opens up across the street. You go there,

41:36 you like it better, and the other poor store goes out of business. Are they entitled some kind of compensation? No, you were entitled. You know, we're made by God with his ability to make our decisions like that. If that's what's you know, causing the chips to fall, you know, then that's you know, we got to accept differences that are gonna be based on that. But if the rules are rigged, you know, that's where we got well that's a different story exactly. Yeah, all together, But I think what's happened in this culture particularly, it seems like in this last generation I've often said, Robert, is that parents are afraid, you know, for their children to get booboos. I say, go out there, you know, go scrape up some knees, go fall out of Remember when you were a kid and you went to the park and it was a big old slide and it was metal, yes, and you first you went down the baby slide, and then you conquered that. Now I'm gonna go down the big slide. Right now, I'm gonna go down head first.

42:35 It took bigger and bigger risks until you kind of like learn what you're you know, how far you could push yourself exactly? Heard you for life, so much better than all of the plastic slides and all the kids and the boo boos that we have today. I am thoroughly convinced of that that we not take enough risks, say, and we certainly saw that with the COVID shutdowns, the tiny, tiny risks that we're going to be from children going to school and changing these germs with each other. The risks were so small, and yet we shut down the schools and they stopped learning, and we just there. I see this in my own students. They're just not as good as the ones that who you know, stayed with it and see it in the test scores. You see it all over the place. So that'd be a kind of rules and social norms, right, what is the social norm about taking risks and about there are some redistributional con you know, conflicts that might arise from a law like that. Some people could get armed, some more germs could be spread around, but other people, you know, you've got to think of the big picture there. So right now, the last chapter in the book is one where I talk about social justice, anti racism in public policy, and we were looking for some of they to write this chapter the people at headquarters, and you're telling you got you got.

43:57 I'm like, I guess I have to write it myself. Nobody else is volunteer because it's it's a very controversial topic. Sure, what I do in the chapters largely have a dialogue with Ibram Kendy, you know, the best selling book and Anti Racism, And I say, let's take his ideas seriously. What policies will we put in place to put people of all different racial, ethnic, whatever groups on an equal footing. He says, scrap capitalism. Capitalism and racism are conjoined twins. Not my reading of history. But if you scrap capitalism, what he gets is socialism. And socialism, of course, just concentrates all the power in a few people at the tops hands instead of diffusing it into the hands of the power is in the hands of the consumers and capitalism right, So socialism concentrates the power and it also leads to horrible outcomes. It leads to construction of prosperity. Look at Venezuela.

44:58 Remember when all the celebrities went there and met Hugo Chavs and talked about how great that economy. Now it's gone down the tubes. There are more people who are refugees from Venezuala. I saw this in the paper the other day, and then there are from Syria. Think about right, So, we don't want people to be on an equal footing down at the bottom of a pit like they are in a socialists. We'd like to have them beyond relatively equal footing near the top of the hill or the top of the mountain. So I say in this chapter, well, here's some policies I think that could do it for us. And I think across if you think about it and we're like rooting for special interests, you would you, I hope book Greek education reform taking the power and putting it into the parents' hands, because they're the ones who know their own children about their children the most right.

45:49 It's a healthcare reform that eliminates barriers on the supply side, that allows it just to get easier for more people to practice medicine and all of its various you know kinds, so that the price of medicine could come down. One of the healthcare reforms that I mentioned in the chapter is that about sixty three percent of all black lives and in abortions. There is something you would seriously want to have a talk about. I talked about occupational licensing, like we talked about earlier exclusionary zoning, which makes it hard for people to move to the most productive areas of the economy because it's so expensive. One hundred years ago, Detroit's the hot place, it's booming. Everybody pulls up steake moves to Detroit. You know, nowadays Silicon Valley wherever, you can't afford to move there because the insiders put in some rules that would benefit them and not the outsiders, right. I also talk about cheap energy. So now they're getting invaded by homeless people that are defecating on your sidewalks. So somehow just for vails, I guess, I don't know, it's just nuts yet.

46:59 I talk about cheap energy. You know, fracking. That's a dirty word in some areas. No, it's not what fracking did. Especially, I think about natural gas, bringing the price of natural gas down, which people use to heat their homes. I cite some statistics in the chapter about how many lives have been saved, an economic study that looked at this, how many lives have been saved due to the cheaper energy, so that people, you know, don't catch as many colds and fluid and whatever and then die in the middle of winder right, and I think about ending they all out, because the thing is is that that's when people die when it gets cold, exactly right. Even in the country of India, there are more cold related deaths than heat related deaths. Okay, so this is I read, you know Willi cather my Antonia, classic work of literature set in the prairies of Nebraska back in the late eighteen hundreds. She's got a chilling quote there about about how cold is our greatest enemy. Yes, cold as much were We're designed to live in hot places. If you think of anything, you know, because when you look, when you look at the history of the world, when the expansion took place, it took it expanded when heat was there, when it was evident, right when there was a clear difference between heat and gold, when it when it constricted, was during the cold periods.

48:19 But I guess you have to ignore were very bad for us. Yeah, yeah, I'm with you on that. So what I you know, I do in the chapter is trying to bring together a lot of things have been published in the Independent Review, the Journal that I added, and you know, other things I've read from many economists. I think these are things that if you weren't worrying about the special interest, you would say, yeah, we should do that policy this, you know, this whole range of policies that will just make life especially better off for the poorest people. The poorest people. Yeah, exactly, what a huge difference. I mean, that's it, and that is an excellent chapter, and and God bless you for taking that on. But I thought in the which you know, the manner in which you you did, uh, I thought you were pretty even handed about it. Because on the title you might think, whoa, we're gonna, you know, really be dealing with something here. There's going to be an imbalance. But I thought that you did a great job in hitting these key points. That's gonna you know, for those for those that will read this and get you, I mean, you want to get your hand on this book. I mean, this is going to go a long way because we firmly believe in this in this show that you know, knowledge is power, and information the right information should lead to the right action, and uh, you know, and this helps us in that direction. Robert, I can't thank you enough for it. It's great. And I tried to in that chapter, and I know that all of our authors trying to this

49:52 to approach this question with humility. Michael, you know I'm not on the exactly God, I'm certainly not. So there are other people who know things that I don't know. And so if we can have a dialogue with those people and have them make their best case and not you know, dismantle their straw man case. There's a new expression. Let make them their steel man case, right, the best case that they can positive maybe even take their case and make it better in ways that they hadn't thought of. And then deal with that best case, your best case against their best case. I think will will you know, lead to constructive outcomes. I always believe in the accumulated the accumulated mindset here and coming together in debating an issue that you know, with many counselors of victory is assured. And you know that with that shared ambition that we would reach for the stars and expand our knowledge and awareness for the greater good of all concerned. Robert rifles again, thank you and the twenty one academics who participated in social justice. Just the book available at all the usual places, right, And how can people be in touch with you? Well, I encourage everybody to go to the website of the Independent Institute and so it's just Independent dot org and you'll see the journal that publish and see all the different publications. We've got all sorts of interesting pro

51:23 projects and videos to see. And if any of your watchers want to contact me, just I'm out there on the web. Google my name and you'll find my email address at my website and send me an email. I'd be happy to talk with you. Look at if the irs can find him, you can find him. So it's not that bad, okay when we know that, Robert, thank you so much for being with us your blessing. Appreciate you. Take care. I am very able to have me on. Thank you. You got it for more information, it'd be a part of this mighty Martinez movement to return to God and to save our country. Hey check it out Bill Martinez show dot com. Hey, God bless you and keep you and make his face shine upon you. Going be blessed beyond your Imagination. Thanks for being with US Stakecare