Bill Martinez Live
Dec. 20, 2023

Biased Media Coverage on Crime

Biased Media Coverage on Crime
Biased Media Coverage on Crime
Bill Martinez Live
Biased Media Coverage on Crime

Dr John Lott, president of the Crime Prevention Research Center and author of “Gun Control Myths” says, “Almost
80% of Americans, and 92% of Republicans, think crime has gone up, It actually fell in 2023.” Yes, murder fell in 2023, but still higher...

Dr John Lott, president of the Crime Prevention Research Center and author of “Gun Control Myths” says, “Almost
80% of Americans, and 92% of Republicans, think crime has gone up, It actually fell in 2023.” Yes, murder fell in 2023, but still higher than in 2018 and 2019. The media might make a big deal about the historically large drop in murder from 2022 to 2023, but they fail to mention that comes after the even bigger historically large increase that occurred between 2019 and 2020.

The Bill Martinez Show is broadcast live Monday - Friday at 1PM ET.

The Bill Martinez TV Show is viewed on Talk 4 TV (www.talk4tv.com).

The Bill Martinez Radio Show is broadcast on W4CY Radio (www.w4cy.com) part of Talk 4 Radio (www.talk4radio.com) on the Talk 4 Media Network (www.talk4media.com).

The Bill Martinez Podcast is also available on Talk 4 Podcasting (www.talk4podcasting.com), iHeartRadio, Amazon Music, Pandora, Spotify, Audible, and over 100 other podcast outlets.

Transcript

0:00 The topics and opinions expressed in the following show are solely those of the hosts and their guests and not those of W FOURCY Radio. It's employees are affiliates. We make no recommendations or endorsements for radio show programs, services, or products mentioned on air or on our web. No liability, explicit or implied shall be extended to W FOURCY Radio or its employees are affiliates. Any questions or comments should be directed to those show hosts. Thank you for choosing W FOURCY Radio. Well, hello and welcome. I'm Bill Martinez and we are live. Good to have you with us. We're going to be talking about the bias media coverage on crime with my good friend doctor John Lott, the president of the Crime Prevention Center and author of Gun Control miss who says that almost eighty percent of Americans ninety two percent of Republicans think crime has gone up and actually it fell in twenty twenty three, Doctor John Lott. Welcome, Michelle. Good to have you with us, Sir, great to talk to you, Thanks for having me on. Well, whether it's the biased media coverage in cabal with the administration and forget about what our Constitution says, it seems that they are both involved in shredding our constitution and leaving us vulnerable because look at let's just deal with the facts and the reality of and again, John, as a key researcher on this issue, you've got the facts to

1:34 bear against their perceptions, right well, I mean, murder is higher now than it was in twenty nineteen, right before the pandemic went into effect, and of course it spiked even higher during twenty twenty and twenty twenty one. And it's not difficult to understand why that happened. I mean, you had judges in many parts of the country releasing half or even two thirds of the inmates from local jails. You had district attorneys and still have district attorneys in many places who were refusing to prosecute violent criminals. You have police department budgets that were cut in twenty twenty, though recently some places have you know, from Austin to Los Angeles to other places, have reversed the cuts that they had made. And you have things like bail reform going on in the country.

2:32 So it's not particularly surprising if you make it less risky for criminals to go and commit crime. You're going to have more crime that's going to be occurring exactly well, not to mention, you got an open border, an open border that has become so dangerous that even the FBI director has the country on red alert. He says that all the lights are are lit up right now when it comes to danger in our country, right. I mean, since and became president, we've had over ten million illegal aliens center in the country. And that's just adding up to parts of the numbers. There the fact that you have people that got turned in that the border patrol is dealing with, and then you have so called guidaways which they see coming across the border but they weren't able to catch. But it doesn't include that. Ten million doesn't even include a third category, and that is illegal aliens that we never caught and didn't see coming across. And God only knows how many of those that are there. Many of those may be among the very worst that you have to worry about. The ones that come in and turn themselves in are probably not ones you need to worry about. But one of the things that's interesting there was a recent Harvard Harris poll that came out that ask Americans, how many illegal aliens do you think have come across in the last year, And it's just unbelievable. You have you have something like fifty percent of

4:05 Democrats, for example, think that it's either less than one hundred thousand or less than two hundred and fifty thousand, I mean one in the book here, Yeah, and one could wish that it was so few that had come across. I mean, you only have literally maybe ten percent that are talking about a couple million or more exactly. And unfortunately, Republicans are also way way, way low, not quite as low as the Democrats are, but you have again, you have something like over thirty percent of Republicans think that almost forty percent actually, who think that less than two hundred and fifty thousand illegally have come in. And so, I mean, one could only imagine if you had all those Democrats and all those Republicans and independents who think that, you know, less than two hundred and fifty thousand have come in, if you told them that the true number was, you know, twenty times or whatever higher than that exactly, then what would their reaction be? Well, I think it's incredulous to them because they've been told the border is secure.

5:27 Majorcas has maintained that line. Joe Biden has maintained that line. The media has just like everything else that we're going to be talking about, the bias media is on the Democratic Party agenda, and so they support the narrative. It's amazing to me because you know, there has been you know, publicity about you know, cities like New York for example, and in all it takes I mean normally, I mean normally this time of year, especially New York City has flooded with you know, with visitors, and it's going to take them two seconds to figure out what the heck is going on here. First of all, they're hard pressed to find a hotel room and they're all booked up. But they're not booked up with you know, regular patrons that are paying this, right, it's with the illegal migrants that Joe Biden has placed in these hotels. All right. Well, one of the things that's interesting is just these polls show that Biden's approval rating for things like how he's handling the border crisis is in the twenty percent range, you know, which is like unbelievably low. So yeah, exactly, right. Well, if it's in the twenty percent range, and it's people think that you're talking about two hundred and fifty thousand or one hundred thousand or less that have been there, one can only imagine, you know, would it be in single

6:58 digits if people knew that the correct number was like twenty times higher than that, I mean, what would it be? So, you know, so one can one can only imagine. And then, of course, as you mentioned, the mainstream media, except for covering how the Democratic mayors and places like New York City and Chicago have been or DC, had been complaining about a few bus loads of illegals showing up in there. They're cities. I mean, compared to the flood in Texas, you know, it's completely insignificant. I mean, you have Eagle Pass, Texas, which has a population of like thirty thousand people, has ten thousand illegal immigrants just camping out in their city. You know. You know, New York City has what eight and a half million something like that, and you have you know, they're they're upset that they have one hundred thousand or so that they're having to deal with, and so you know, it's a percentage of their population. It's it's trivial compared to what communities from San Antonio and Egle Pass and El Paso and other places are having to deal with. Yeah, it's just it's so overwhelming and and it and you know, the other thing that is not happening, and that is their reporting by the mainstream media of the illegals who are

8:31 murdering America's citizens, right right, Well, I mean, obviously there are a lot of them who aren't criminals, but presumably you want to go and identify which ones are criminals and which one's not in any normal immigration policy that you're going to have, and there's really no controls and and you know, they go and ask people what their name is or whatever, but people could be making up names. There's no way to check people coming in from a number of different countries, and they don't even try checking them. Even people that have been on the terror watch list have been released into the country.

9:13 Uh, you know. And and when Biden administration officials have testified before Congress and members of Congress have asked them, what's happened to the terror watchless people that they've released and where are they? They can't tell you where they are. Yeah, now there's there's danger all around here. And meanwhile they continue to stonewall and and lie to the American people about the situation, and uh, you know, and and meanwhile, the other thing is that's going on, John, these these migrants they come across there beholden the cartels. See even my orcist doesn't even understand why they're wearing wristbands. The wristbands is an indication as to what part of the cartel machinery within the United States, you know, what their job will be, you know, from human trafficking, sex trafficking, fentanyl, drug, you know, you name it all down the line that you know, the cartels have had a windfall. I think last year was something like thirteen billion dollars. This year we haven't hit the registered total button yet, but it's going to be at least that plus tax and license and inflation on top of it. Right. Well, I mean, obviously the cartel in many different ways has benefited a lot from having these

10:43 open borders. But it's not just the cartels. You have many smaller operations. I mean, when you have very strict enforcement of the border, it's basically only the large cartels that are very successful in getting large amounts of drugs into the States. But now you have many other players that are becoming enriched, and it's going to be hard to put the genie back in the bottle there with all the money that these organizations are obtaining. But John, see, this is just going to add to the crime rate even more so, don't you think I mean not to mention, you know, we haven't even touched on this, and this is the psychological impact on everyday citizens here.

11:28 You know, you've got people that you know, are still buying guns and they're you know, stocking up ammunition because danger just seems so imminent. Right Well, I mean, there are lots of different causes for that. I was just reading an article earlier today about how Jews in Los Angeles and of course other places in the country are going out and buying guns. But you know, I think what's happening is people are beginning to wake up and understand that, look, if the government's not able to protect you, and the government and the police, while they're extremely important in reducing crime, the police themselves understand that they virtually always arrive on the crime scene after the crimes occurred.

12:13 And the question is what should people do when they're having to confront a criminal by themselves, and it turns out that by far the safest course of action is to have a gun. And that's particularly true, I would argue, for the most vulnerable people in our society, people who are relatively weaker physically, women and the elderly. You're almost always talking about young men doing the violent crime. The attack there, and when a man is attacking a woman as a much larger strength difference that exists there than when a man is attacking another man. And the other group of people who benefit the most are the ones who are the most likely victims of violent crime, and that overwhelmingly tends to be poor blacks who live in high crime urban areas. You know.

13:03 So we're in this weird world that you and I have talked about before where Democrats have made it difficult for law enforcement to do its job in many areas, and at the same time they want to make it difficult for people to be able to go and protect themselves. And so the question is what's the alternative. I mean, it's just everything you can do to make it easier for criminals to go and commit crime. And the thing is, you know, This isn't rocket science. If you make it less risky for people to go and commit crime, they're going to go and commit more crime. And it's not just the direct victims of violent crime that are harmed from that.

13:43 What you have is many indirect ways. So it's you know, obviously family members of crime victims, but people tend to commit crimes and areas where they live nearby against similar people. So about ninety of murders of blacks are committed by blacks. And so, you know, democrats may be concerned about equity in terms of, you know, making sure that people get to go to prison at the same rate for each population, each group of the population there, but the victims of violent crime tend to be the same types of people, poor blacks who live in high crime urban areas. But it's not just that. It's who owns many of the stores that close down or pay the higher prices in those stores, who works in those stores, who lives in those communities whose property values are depressed because of the higher crime rates that occur. All those you know, Democrats claim that they care about the poor, that they care about blacks, that they care about women, and yet the types of policies that they go and push. Those are the victims.

15:01 Yeah, it just doesn't make sense. We're talking about doctor John Lotte, president of the Crime Prevention Research Center and the author of gun Control. Miss John, We've got to you know, the graphs that you had produced regarding biased media coverage on crime almost eighty percent of Americans, ninety two percent of Republicans. Then crime has gone up, it actually fell, you say, in twenty twenty three. And I want to pull up the first graph that shows the FBI murder rate if you can explain that to our audience. Right, Well, obviously there was a big increase in murder rates in twenty twenty and twenty twenty one. There was some decline in twenty twenty two, and there was an additional decline in twenty twenty three, but it's still above what it was before the pandemic. So the media is out there talking about the big drop, but they seem to ignore was that there was an even larger increase that had occurred in twenty twenty. And the thing is there issues with the new FBI data for murder compared to what it was in twenty nineteen, because in the last couple of years. A lot of big cities where a lot of the murders have been occurring, haven't been reporting their data to the FBI, and so there's some other people that have tried to collect the data.

16:34 Cities like Los Angeles and New York didn't report their crime data last year to the FBI. Now they still have it. You can go and look down the city websites and you can go and find it. It just wasn't reported to the FBI. So there are people out there that have gone and collected the data that these cities are putting out there even if the FBI isn't getting it. And it looks like there was a smaller drop in twenty twenty three if you use this other data than the FBI data. In fact, if you make a comparison between twenty twenty three and in twenty nineteen, the murder rate was still over seven percent higher using that data in twenty twenty three than it was in twenty nineteen. Well, John, I mean, this just has to drive you nuts as a researcher because you're sitting there, you know, you're thinking you can rely on the FBI, and they seem to be very casual about this, because then what happens is people will quote these numbers because that's why they do this research. They can help justify their agenda.

17:52 Right. Well, Unfortunately, I think the FBI. I mean I've used FBI crime data for forty years now, and I've never felt the way I do these days about their data. I mean, part of it is the fact that I worked at the US Department of Justice in twenty nineteen and twenty twenty, and you know, I guess I've gotten to the point where I'm skeptical of a lot of different types of data that the FBI puts out. Unfortunately, I think there have been political biases and other things that have been there, you know, things like hate crime data, where you have subjective calls about whether to classify something as a hate crime or not. I think that there are real problems with I think there's real problems with their active shooting reports that get a lot of media attention. And I think, unfortunately, even if it's not as obvious political bias that's there. I think there have been problems with the crime data over the last couple of years too.

19:02 And you know, and John, when you when you go to report on this and point out the discrepancy. I mean, my goodness, I would think that they would want to listen to you because you're you're you're a researcher. I mean, you're looking at numbers, you're processing data, you're on top of it, not some staffer associated with some you know, congressmen or congresswoman or senator. You you probably have forgotten more than they'll ever learn. And instead, when you lay the facts out out to the they're they're challenging you, and you it's sometimes I have to laugh and I'm going, these are the numbers. How can you review the numbers? Right? Well, I worked in the federal government in the nineteen eighties. I was chief Economists for the US Sentencing Commission, and more recently I was Senior Advisor for Research and Statistics in the US Department of Justice. And I have to say, in the nineteen eighties, when you'd go and point out air in the data, people would fix them. That wasn't the case in twenty nineteen and twenty twenty when I was working there. When you go and point out errors, people would either not respond or they would you know, even if you could get people to concede that they were errors there, they would refuse to fix them, things that I point out they still haven't fixed even years later now.

20:30 And you know, something like the active shooting reports where police departments don't collect that data and you have to go and you know, they'll hire people to go and look at news stories to collect those. I can understand why people can miss finding all the news stories, even if they spend millions of dollars on something like that. But you know, it's one thing to miss it to begin with. It's another thing not to fix it when somebody points out to you news stories that you've missed. And unfortunately, I think in that case, it's pretty clear that they have a political agenda there, because the cases that they miss are systematically cases where people use guns to stop what would have been active shooting cases and anyway. Well, but it seems to be, you know, a disease within the bureaucracy stemming from that old concept of it it's good enough for government work. So whether you're counting votes or registering voters. You know, so what if you got three million dead people on their roles? Not that big a deal. See, So, this casual attitude, it permeates every aspect of you know, of the institutions, and so then when we go to have a fair minded debate and discussion because we want to fix the problem, your data is compromised. Well, if your data is compromised, I got to believe that's going to have an effect on the solution. And is it not, John Well, I don't know

22:03 how you can even know whether there's a problem to fix unless you go and look at the data that's there. People have to rely on it, and then how you're going to fix it, it's going to be depending upon you know, how you measure the problem and what you think the different solutions are. And the only way you can even test different solutions and look at different places that have tried different ways of fixing things is by seeing how the data changes after they've changed their policies. But it's you know, it's not just sloppiness or laziness. I mean, it may be sometimes that that's the case, and that's you know, probably the simplest explanation to go and point to.

22:44 But when you're talking about something like the active shooting reports, where you know, people point out, I point out that they've missed news stories. People nobody needs to believe me about these things. You can go to our website at crimeresearch dot org and if you go and you click on the links at the top for our recent research there, you'll quickly find our reports on active shooting cases exactly. And nobody needs to take my word for it. We have the cases that the FBI is listed. We have like one hundred and fifty cases that we say that they've missed over the nine years from twenty fourteen through twenty twenty two, cases where guns were used to stop these active shooting cases. And so there are two things. One is, it's one thing to miss cases, but it seems very systematic because the cases that they've missed are all cases where people use guns to stop attacks exactly. They also misclassified things. You have something like the White Settlement church shooting near Fort Worth, Texas in December twenty nineteen. You know, in that situation, they classified the individual who stopped the attack as a security guard, so they didn't

24:18 chalk it up as a civilian stopping the attack. Well, when I was at the Department of Justice, I called up the man who stopped the attack. He said, you know, maybe they gave people the title honorary security guard. But basically the minister there had said, anybody who has a concealed care permit, just carry and we'll just call you an honorary security guard. There was no additional training, there's no fees that they were paid, there was no anything. It's just you were a parishioner, you had a concealed carry permit, you were welcome to do it. And in fact, on the day that the attack occurred, they can't even tell you how many permit holders were there. They think at some place between like eighteen and twenty.

25:03 It's because the church wasn't taking you know, keeping track of who was carrying or who wasn't. It was just anybody who had a permit was able to carry there. But on the national average, John, isn't it about fifteen percent of the country has a consial carry permit. Roughly well, about about eight percent of adults in the United States have a conceal carry permit. If you remove California and New York from the totals, you're talking about something about ten and a half percent. But now they're like these twenty seven constitutional carry states where you don't need to have a permit. We've recently put out our report on this our annual report, and we hired McLaughlin and associates to go and do a survey of whether people carry. And what we found was that about fifteen point six percent of adults voters general election voters in the United States said that they carried concealed handguns for protection. And that's that's quite a significant increase from a Pew survey that was done about five years ago. And so, you know, you have a situation where it's pretty clear that you can explain the number of people who carry based on the costs. I'll give you a simple example. Compare Illinois in Indiana. In Indiana, about twenty three

26:37 percent of the adult population is a concealed carry permit. In Illinois it's about four percent. Why the difference, Well, in Illinois, if you add up the cost of the fees and the training and what have you, you're talking about something that's like four hundred and fifty dollars to go and get a concealed carry permit. In Indiana, it's literally zero dollars. They don't even charge you for doing the background check. There. We make it more costly. You get pure people who are going to be doing it. It's not, you know, just simple economics there, But it's more than that because it not only affects the number of people who carry, but it affects the mix of people who carry. So in Illinois, it's basically wealthy people who live in the suburbs who are carrying concealed handgun permits. In Indiana, you see a lot more people with permits in urban, heavily minority poor areas.

27:38 And you know, just so if you want to reduce crime, you have to make it risky for criminals to commit crime. The greater the percentage of people carrying, the greater the reduction. But it matters who's carrying. I can't have one hundred percent of the population carrying, but if it's in an area where there's no crime, I'm not going to get any reduction in crime. They have them carrying in the high crime areas, and so in Illinois you're going to get a much smaller reduction in crime because you have fewer people carried. But I think even more important, the people who are carrying are carrying in areas where there's not a lot of crime. In Indiana, not only do you have a lot more people carrying but you have the people who are the most likely victims carrying, and so you're making it riskier, much riskier for criminals to attack people in Indiana than you are in Illinois. Yeah.

28:33 Well, and the other thing too, in terms of like a bell curve shape here, John, I would think would exist is that, Yes, in these areas where you know, these wealthier areas and they're able to afford the costs of a gun and all the licensing and everything like that, I can imagine in the in the poorer areas, that's where you've got people that you know, have guns, but they don't care about no stinking law. You know, they're just going to carry the gun because, you know, because they're criminals. Right Well, I mean that's the problem. You know. You go and you pass these laws, and it's something you and I have talked about many times. You have to be careful that the law doesn't primarily disarm law abiding, good citizens to take something simple like these gun free zones that you have. You and I have talked about this, and it's something that really upsets me. You know, talk about media bias.

29:33 The media just refuses, just absolutely refuses to go and cover what these murders say in their manifestos and diaries about why they picked the targets that they did. Over and over again. They explain that they want to commit suicide, but they want to go to a place where they can kill lots of people because they want to get media coverage. And they know that the more people they can hill, the more media coverage that they're going to get. If they go to a place where their victims are not able to defend themselves, they're going to be able to go and kill more people and get more media coverage. But the thing is, take something like the Nashville school shooting earlier this year, right, if you or I carried a gun into a school zone, we'd be facing six years in prison. Well six years in prison, your life, my life would be completely changed as a result of that.

30:34 But let's say you're the murderer there who murdered six people, and assuming that they had lived, Okay, they died at the scene, but and as often the case, but let's say that they had lived, they'd be facing six life sentences or six death penalties. Would an additional six years matter to them? You're saying, Wow, you know you're going to take six years from their seventh life there, you know that that's good. That's going to stop them. They're going to be concerned about that. I mean, it's ridiculous. It represents no real additional penalty for those individuals, okay, compared to a law abiding citizen there whose life would be completely demolished if they did. So, what does the law do. I understand the desire behind the law. I understand the desire is to create a safe area. But what happens is the oppos because because the murderer there knows that the victims will be defenseless, because it represents a big penalty for them if they were to go and have a gun. But the murderer takes advantage of that. The murderer talks about that and their diaries and manifests those saying, you know, they know that their victims are going to be defenseless, and that will allow them to kill more people and therefore get more media coverage. And so it Actually, these gun free zones actually serve as a magnet exactly to go and do these attacks. Just put a target all over these gun free zones.

32:06 That's why I told you the story here in Florida when I went to a theater and they had signs all over the front of the building this is a gun free zone. I went to the manager, I said, do you realize what you're doing with that? Well it's company. Well no, you've just put a crosshair a target on every one of the patrons here. Needless to say, I ignored their stink and sign. I'm not going to be in that kind of situation. And now I just all together, I just don't go to that theater. It's just absolutely stupid that they would do that. And then, speaking of manifestos, we still haven't got the full manifesto from what happened in Nashville. A little bit leaked out, but three page points. Yeah, but to your point, you know, she decided not to. I mean, the reason she picked that one school was because she knew that there wasn't anybody there that was going to fire back at her the other school that she had picked it. You know, she realized the mall right, exactly, she was gonna have a b right, No, it's exactly. I mean the Nashville police chief, who did get a look at the diary there, made the exact point that you're making. He said, that the murderers original primary target had been had been the nearby mall there, but that they had looked into it and realized that people had guns concealed handguns and would be there to stop them. And so the murder there, you

33:37 know, therefore picked the school for precisely the reason that you say that they knew that there wasn't gonna be anybody there to go and stop them. Right. Well, John in uh, you know at your website you evaluate well you basically you read that you collected the data that evaluated President Biden and handling crime and law enforcement issues. I want to bring that to graph up now. And this is a national survey of eight hundred and ninety two US likely voters was conducted between December sixth and seven. And this was just this year, December sixth and seventh and the tenth of twenty twenty three, and Rasmussen reported the following. So go ahead and explain to our audience how that came out. Right. Well, you know, Americans, even people who are you know, considered Democratic supporters, are pretty much down on how well Biden has been doing with regard to crime. Some of the things that I find particularly interesting is that the people who are most upset are basically poor people, people, people with relatively low educations, the people that you think are most likely victims of violent crime. The people who don't aren't as upset are people

35:09 who are graduate school education, people who make like over two hundred thousand dollars a year. And you know, so you have a group of people that are kind of isolated from the problems that they're creating for others. You know, they live in their safe communities and what have you. But the people who actually have to live with the outcomes from these solutions are the ones who are who are most concerned about the problems that are there. Well, what do you make John, I mean, you've got DC experience, and when we've got lawmakers that have been you know, cars have been you know, they've been car drected. You know, so some of this stuff is starting to come home, you know, to these lawmakers that you know, that have created I would say, in a lot of ways, they've created a lot of the problem. Right. Well, I mean, and you've seen some reversal, uh, you know, a significant reversal in things like uh uh police funding. Police funding had been cut in a number of places and they've reversed that. You know, how can they recoverage? But how can they recover? John? I mean you when you do this kind of damage to everyday people. I mean, these are you know, law enforcement officers.

36:35 Uh, you know, with a lot of experience, and you put them under this kind of pressure. You have a situation like what what happened with Derek Chauvin uh and other things that have happened. Uh in terms of the prejudice against law enforcement. Uh, these guys are going, hey, you know what, I'm going to go in the life insurance business. Uh. I don't need to put my livelihood and you know, my retirement on the line for people that are not going to appreciate me. Right. Well, I mean you can hire new officers and train them. I mean, it may not happen instantly that you're going to be able to replace the people.

37:16 Plus it takes, you know, a couple of years for officers to get the experience that they need to kind of be as effective as they would be. But you know, to be honest, I think one of the reasons why people in these cities they wanted to drive out a lot of the older officers there and one of the reasons why I think they wanted to do that is if you look at surveys of police officers, you find that they tend to be extremely conservative on lots of issues, including gun control and what have you. And I think part of what was going on is that the liberals the Democrats who were running these areas, thought that they could bring in new young officers that they could go and train with the views that they want them to have, and they could get rid of the older officers. And I think you know that they've been part of what they were thinking. Well, well, John, look at you know, you kind of touched on this a little bit, and maybe we can unwrap this a little bit more because you know your research, you're looking outside of the United States and seeing what other countries, what they've done in Europe with this, and they seem to be a little bit more objective, at least in my humble opinion, what I'm reading is that they're giving you real numbers where the kind of information

38:49 that you get here in this country, as evidenced by this media report, it is quite biased. What's what's your determination based on what you're seeing that's happening overseas versus what's happening here in America. I mean, Europe has had increases in violent crime. They've had a large influx of immigrants into the area there, many of them illegal. And you know, Europe though, has better data in terms of kind of monitoring the number of people that have been coming into their countries, usually because it's at the country level and there has been research out there. I did something for real clear investigations recently, but basically, the countries that have had the biggest increases in illegal immigration have had the biggest increases and murder rates r and so you can go and do that type of study. In the United State, we don't know. You know, it's hard enough to get data on the number that are coming into the country, but to go and get it broken down at the state level, it's pretty much non existent exactly. So you know, what you'd like to try to do is to go and to see whether those states in the US

40:21 which have had the biggest increases in illegal immigrants, how their crime rates have changed. But unfortunately, as I say, that data is not readily available. Well, John, what about in terms of you know, these crimes and these murders that involved involved guns. I mean, because a lot of these countries they've outlawed guns. I mean, you can't have a gun, you know. I mean it's you know, concealed carry in you can't have won legally. But right, so, okay, a couple points one is over ninety two percent of violent crime in the United States has nothing at all to do with guns in any way. I know there's so much discussion about gun crime. President Biden talks about it constantly, but you know, it seems to me, whether somebody is assaulted or harmed with a gun or without a gun, you know, a woman's right without a gun or rape with it, it's you know, it's pretty bad in either case. And you know, the way you reduce gun crime generally is the same way that you go and reduce this other ninety two percent of violent crime, and that is you make it risky for criminals to go and commit crimes. Unfortunately, President

41:51 Biden, you will search in vain to find him criticizing the district attorneys that have been releasing inmates. You won't find any discussions about him about bail reform. You won't find any discussions of him criticizing liberal judges that have been releasing these large numbers of inmates. As I said earlier, in many urban areas in twenty twenty, twenty twenty one, and even the beginning of twenty twenty two, you'd see, you know, in some urban areas half or even two thirds of the inmates being released from jails. There. No, it's you know, it's a real problem. Yeah, here you are. You're in a sense, you're importing, kind of like what we've done with our open borders, were importing in some cases, you say, hatred and evil into it. And then now all of a sudden you open up the floodgates and you have people who already have problem issues with their criminality, and you just dumped them. You dumped them into a society. I mean, what is all that about? Somehow, I guess for the sake of equity or justices they perceive it. But this is a serious experiment, and it seems that with the Democratic Democratic Party, especially John, that they like to operate in the realm of the theoretical. You know, everything's on a theory with them. But the deal is is, after everything is all said and done,

43:23 as you mentioned, you're hard pressed to get the data to say, Okay, let's you know, we did this based on your theory and we went into this grand experiment. What's the results. There's no accountability on this, and so how can you determine whether or not you made the right or wrong decision and what adjustments you need to make. Meanwhile, you're leaving the citizens, you know, buck naked and exposed here right. Well, look, I mean the relationship seems pretty clear to me and to you. You know, if you want to reduce crime, you have to make it risk here for criminals to go and commit crime. It's pretty much it's not just John. I mean, you know you've said that several times. And I hope our audience, hope the viewers are catching this. This isn't in a lot of ways. It's not rocket science, is it, right. Look, anybody who's had a dog or a child or something like that, if a dog does something wrong, you punish them. You don't reward them for doing it. If you want the dog to stop doing it, you have to make it clear to the dog that it's not behavior that makes you happy, okay, and that there are consequences to the dog for doing that.

44:40 And if the dog doesn't think that there are any consequences, or it thinks that they're going to be able to get away with that behavior. Then you're going to have more of that undesired behavior that's going to be there. The same thing is true with kids. I mean, maybe it's just as simple as letting the kid know that you're really disappointed in what they're doing, but it has to be some type of consequence there, or you're going to get more of that bad behavior. Yeah, you kind of you kind of wonder maybe the Liberals never had any kids, or maybe they didn't know how to raise their kids or something. I have no idea, but it just, you know, it's a puzzle that people don't seem to understand this view.

45:24 I mean, I can't tell you the number of Soros prosecutors that I've heard make the statement that, you know, putting people in prison or jail for going in committing crimes, you know, doesn't have any effect on the crime rate. You know that they think that they can cut the prison population by half or two thirds or whatever and there won't be any consequence. You know. One of the things that happened during the pandemic, as I say, you had these liberal judges releasing large numbers of inmates. But you know, the bizarre thing was, I mean, we knew pretty early on, even surely by the fall of twenty twenty, that COVID was really only a problem for people who were elderly or who had certain comorbidities. The types of people that you have in jails in prison aren't that way. I mean, the overwhelming majority of people who are in jails in prison are you know, like eighteen twenties, you know, early thirties. You know, that's the vast majority of people who are in jail there and so, and the vast majority of those are healthy physically, and so. You know, it's but those were the ones who were largely being released. And it doesn't make any sense to me why, you know. But yet, even though we knew that those were not the people who were susceptible to this, you still had liberal

46:59 judges and whatever who were still willing to go and release them. They viewed it as, unfortunately, I think, more as you know, something that they could use as an excuse to accomplish the policy goals that they wanted to accomplish. Well, look at the disaster of the summer of love. How many billions of dollars were just you know, vapored businesses, destroyed, jobs lost across the country. It's just absolutely heartbreaking what's happened. And this was all, you know, exacerbated by these liberal judges and prosecutors that kept doing exactly what you've cited, is they incentivized all this bad behavior. And even in California, I mean, you could smash and grab up to one thousand dollars without any accountability. And I mean it's crazy to watch this on television, John, and you say, wait a minute, this cannot be happening in America. Oh, yeah, it's happening. And that's why all these businesses are moving out of these big cities. Yeah. No, they're closing down your places like San Francisco, where you kind of wonder, you know, where you're gonna get a Walgreens or a CVS. And even when they do have those stores, everything is locked up behind glass cases, so to try to prevent people from stealing things. It's really and of course that's more

48:30 costly. It slows down how quickly you can go and buy things in a store because you have to wait for somebody to come by and lock the cabinet for you. You can't go and read the you know, the print on the package to kind of find out whether it's really the type of thing that you want to get or not. I'll tell the people that are perpetrating the smashing grab they don't care about any label. And there isn't some little little, simple little lock that's going to lock up that glass shelf. It's going to slow them down. I mean it, It is so absurd on so many levels. You're exactly right, John, We got to leave it there. As always, we appreciate all the information and what you've shared with us today. Remind people where they can go to stay on top and you know, follow the issues in this coming year. Well thanks and merry Christmas.

49:24 But people can go to our website at crimeresearch dot org. Crimeresearch dot org, and you know, at once every two weeks we send out an email to let people know about the research that we've been doing, and you know, I hope people will consider signing up for that. You know, it doesn't do us any good to do the research on these various topics unless you know, the whole point of it is to kind of educate people on them. Exactly. And oh yeah, by the way, there's a donate button, so if you need to do something for taxes and a good place to donate, donate and help the cause here because of the great work that they're doing on behalf of we the people. Doctor John Lott, thank you so much. God bless you, and Merry Christmas to you, buddy. Take care. Thank you for being there, Bill, Thank you, you got it. Doctor John Lott, president of the Crime Prevention Research Center and author of Gun Control miss Thank you so much for sharing a part of your day with us, for you know, tuning in. And may God bless you and keep you, may make his face shine upon you, may be gracious unto you and give you peace. Thanks again, Merry Christmas. Take care,